> An alphabetic list isn't
And this, and nothing else, is what we're talking about.
Here's the post that I responded to.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5342078
> the arrangement of a phone book is copyrightable
An alphabetical list is not copyrightable, but you can arrange a phonebook to make it copyrightable.
The arrangement of a phonebook can be copyrightable.
The arrangement was copyrightable. An alphabetic list isn't, but arranging that list turns it into something copyrightable.