News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Home sales fell 41% year over year in February, but press... by JacobAldridge on Thursday March 26, 2009 @08:03PM (#534381)
October news: "Pumpkin Sales up 1000%" November news: "Pumpkin Sales plummet"

Month on month tells us nothing (in this extreme example). Year-on-year (ie, Oct 09 v Oct 08) give us an indication of strength or otherwise in a market, without seasonable variations.

Having worked with 120+ Real estate agencies (in Australia - US cycle will differ) I can tell you that every year Jan will be 'down' from Dec, Feb will be up, September will always show an increase over August, and Dec will usually be bigger than Nov.

Reporting just those figures would look like the 'housing market' was an unpredictable roller coaster - up one month, down the next, when will it end, think of the children!?

Sure, in many instances (your business cashflow, for instance) both data points are useful. But year-on-year removes more variables and is therefore more important.

Re:Home sales fell 41% year over year in February, but press... by ellyagg on Friday March 27, 2009 @01:04AM (#534731)
This doesn't address my criticism in the slightest, and I'm extremely well aware of all of this. My comment did not concern what statistics the press should report in presenting financial data, only the lie of the original headline which suggested that the press incorrectly thought homes sales went up when they actually went down. For the scope that the press intended, the stats they reported were accurate.

To reiterate (and not to clarify, because my original comment is clear): When the press reports rises and declines, if they do not explicitly say year over year, they are talking month over month. Indeed, this VERY article contains an example of it, with the press reporting that home sales were up 4.7%. The original title of this submission, before it was edited to include "year over year", specifically played upon this implied and incorrect comparison to provoke a response.

Indeed, I'm not the only one who found the headline misleading; my comment had been voted up to at least 5 shortly after I posted, and before the headline was altered and your tangential comment sent people on a wild goose chase.

Re:Home sales fell 41% year over year in February, but press... by nathanwdavis on Thursday March 26, 2009 @10:47PM (#534566)
The term 'Seasonally Adjusted' means they even these seasonal tendencies out- thus giving meaning to month-over-month % changes. So it is not the same as your Pumpkin Sales example.
Re:Home sales fell 41% year over year in February, but press... by DougBTX on Thursday March 26, 2009 @08:27PM (#534412)
Was this a reply to karl11's comment? [http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=534333]
Re:Home sales fell 41% year over year in February, but press... by azanar on Thursday March 26, 2009 @08:35PM (#534422)
It could be taken as a reply to both. To karl11's comment, it could taken as a caution not to read too much in MoM sales figures. Some of (a lot of?) the variation seen could just be seasonal variation, or even insignificant noise.
Re:Home sales fell 41% year over year in February, but press... by JacobAldridge on Thursday March 26, 2009 @08:36PM (#534423)
Not directly, though karl11 and ellyagg both made similar points about the author's criticism of month-on-month stats.

Ellyagg also said "This post's headline is needlessly provocative and misleading." , which prompted me to respond.

Re:Home sales fell 41% year over year in February, but press... by karl11 on Thursday March 26, 2009 @08:46PM (#534434)
I would agree with you completely. I would point out that for a media and public concerned with the current state of our economy, a year over year statistic is useless. Everyone knows that housing prices are down significantly from the same time last year. A month over month increase sparks hope. An argument about whether or not month over month numbers are valid is one I'm not educated enough to make. I am merely stating that it makes perfect sense for the media to report those stats the way they did, and it isn't because they can't read data.