News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The enigma of the Ford paradox by graycat on Thursday March 07, 2013 @10:32AM (#5338152)
When I was a senior in college, I went through the math of the double pendulum. The subject is mostly just ordinary differential equations although there is a cute role for a little matrix theory.

Generally it seems to me that the OP gets off into some not very well defined and not very relevant topics and, instead, for the 'chaos' he is observing there's a fairly easy explanation: The system is unstable. Or, in one step more detail, the system really is an initial value problem for an ordinary differential equation, but, going way back to Bellman's work on stability theory, it's long been well known, just from the equations, that the solution can be 'unstable', that is, small changes in the initial conditions (values) can result in large changes in the solution. And that is just from ordinary differential equations without considering quantum mechanics. And for the 'chaos' in the OP, that's about all the explanation that is needed.

Why? Because there is really no chance that the motion of the system could be periodic or even simple because it nearly never gets back accurately enough to an earlier state. So, the system often gets back to something 'close' to an earlier state, but the system is so unstable that 'close' is not close enough so that the earlier state and the present one close to that earlier state soon result in very different solutions for the future.

Something similar happens with pseudo random number generators, e.g., the usual linear congruential generators where we set

R(n + 1) = ( A * R(n) + B ) mod C

for n = 1, 2, ..., and R(1) some positive integer. Then roughly the R(n)/C are independent, identically distributed, uniform on [0,1). One of Knuth's recommendations (in one of the volumes of TACP) was A = 5^15, B = 1, C = 2^47. So, a point here is, get such 'random' numbers without considering phase space or quantum mechanics.

In a sense, this is a very old point: E.g., one dream before about 1900 was that we could observe the present state of the world and, then, use deterministic physics to predict the future. So, as I recall, it was E. Borel who did a calculation and concluded that a change of moving 1 gram of matter 1 cm, or some such, on a distant star would invalidate predictions on earth after just milliseconds (presumably starting after the travel time of light from that star to the earth).

We suspect we see much the same in weather prediction: Small changes in initial conditions too soon make changes large enough to switch between rain and sunshine. The usual joke is that a butterfly could flap its wings and convert a clear day to a hurricane.

We anticipate that probabilistically weather prediction is quite stable, that is, what is stable is the conditional probability distribution of the variables we use to measure weather conditioned on the present. In particular, we still believe in the law of conservation of energy.

Also we should notice the classic work on ergodic theory, by Hopf, Poincare, Birkhoff, etc.: The standard illustration is pouring cream into coffee and stirring. Then the theorem says that, if stir long enough, then can make the cream separate from the coffee back to as close as please to the original state. Why? Because if take the 'volume' of the possible states at some point in time and then let time pass, then the 'volume' of those states is still the same. So, as the system evolves, it is 'measure preserving' in state space. So, if want to apply this to a frictionless double pendulum, then can get it to return as close as we please to its initial state, but between then and now it is free to do a lot. This stuff goes back to the first half of the last century.

Likely there are some interesting and important questions in chaos theory, but what the OP is saying about the double pendulum seems to have a simple explanation.

There are no comments on this comment yet.