News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by crusso on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @06:41PM (#5334845)
Unless Walmart is in control of all jobs in the market or unless Walmart and other employers are illegally colluding by sticking to a low wage agreement - the value of productivity per hour is what workers at Walmart are negotiating.

If Walmart isn't paying people what they feel they are worth then they're free to go elsewhere to redefine what their labor is worth.

just be taken out of that job and subsidized by the state wholesale

That completely eliminates the ability of some to find part time work to supplement their income. Maybe a mom without any real skills in the job market would like to work a few extra hours at an entry level job to bring home some spending money for herself and her family. Maybe a teenager would like to get some experience and earn some gas money while in high school.

By eliminating jobs through manipulating the minimum wage so thoughtlessly, you would destroy vital segments of the job market that serve a purpose.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by likeclockwork on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @07:12PM (#5335000)
There is no negotiation.

This is Walmart, not silicon valley.

You don't like what we're paying? Starve, see if we care, we'll find someone who will work for half what we offered you and let us throw paint on him to boot.

These jobs aren't taken by people whose needs are taken care of and are just looking for a little 'pocket money' or some gas so they can take the old car around and see their buddies on weekends.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by illuminate on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @10:47PM (#5335943)
"Starve, see if we care"

Even if they like what Walmart is paying, their workers are still on food stamps.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @05:31AM (#5337008)
And there is the issue!

The rest of us, through taxes, are already subsidising the big corps and their minimum wage employees. We do this because people shouldn't have to starve in the modern world, but where people are employed we shouldn't need to.

By forcing a raise in the minimum wage we stop the employer from taking from our collective pocket to support their broken business model.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by nathan_long on Thursday March 07, 2013 @07:37AM (#5337284)
But what's the root issue? Worker X is not able to produce value of more than $X an hour. Do we mandate he/she is paid more anyway, or do we try to train and educate a workforce that can produce more value?
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:19AM (#5337405)
Why must it be that the worker isn't producing the value?

Worker X may be producing value of $10X or $20X per hour, but corporation Y is pocketing the difference, and can do so because there is an oversupply of workers.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by crusso on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:28AM (#5337448)
You are not fully understanding where the $10X or $20X value comes from. It doesn't come from the low skilled workers. It comes from the huge amount of automation, computerization, business process, and infrastructure all around that unskilled person.

If I work twenty years and invest all my spare money to build a fabulous machine that produces intricate and expensive electronics but the one thing I don't do is create a way to turn it on and off automatically. I hire a person to just sit there and push the button. This person needs almost no skills whatsoever.

Is this person really vital to producing my $100X per hour? In a way, yes. But then again, since this person's skills are non-existent - this person can be replaced by anyone else who can push a button.

I invested in the invention and the creation of the machine. I took the risk to build the machine. I spent the twenty years of my life dedicated to it. I created the environment where any half sentient being could push the button to get the thing going. Everything I did created the $100X per hour.

The person pushing the button doesn't deserve $100X per hour. The person pushing the button deserves the wages for someone with the skills to push a button.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:35AM (#5337479)
Deserve? Oh my, have I crossed some randian moral-boundary here? My word... leeches and moochers everywhere!

If you're not going to pay a living wage, what makes you think you DESERVE to have a worker there pushing the button?

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by crusso on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:54AM (#5337539)
That person deserves what the market pays for people with that particularly low skill set. It's not totally up to me. Maybe I live in an area where wages are really high. In that case, I'm going to have to pay the going rate for someone with low skills.

"living wages" are crap. They completely ignore the fact that some workers are young or spousal dependents looking for that part-time job to earn a little money.

On top of that there is no such thing as a "living wage" that can be defined. If I'm living alone, young, healthy, and not real picky about my lifestyle -- a living wage can be $1000 per month. If I'm married with 5 kids and in need of constant medical care, a living wage is 6X higher.

Yet you're implying that I as an employer with my available job for someone to push a friggin' button has to worry about all that or at very least accept someone's opinion on the lowest common denominator living wage?

At that point, I say screw the high school kid or part-time mom looking to earn a little extra money pushing the button. I automate the whole damned thing and eliminate the job. That, my friend, is called the "unintended consequence" of your heavy handed approach of controlling every little perceived injustice.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @09:10AM (#5337608)
"That person deserves what the market pays for people with that particularly low skill set"

So I'm right, you do consider this a moral issue, you think that the free market is the be-all and end-all of morality and that people only 'deserve' what you deign to hand to them.

"Yet you're implying that I as an employer with my available job for someone to push a friggin' button has to worry about all that or at very least accept someone's opinion on the lowest common denominator living wage?"

You're the one that came up with the dumb button example.

Sounds like you don't really need someone to press the button anyway. If it was vital to your operations you'd be prepared to pay decently as it's not you've made a saving. Good for you.

"At that point, I say screw the high school kid or part-time mom looking to earn a little extra money pushing the button. I automate the whole damned thing and eliminate the job. That, my friend, is called the "unintended consequence" of your heavy handed approach of controlling every little perceived injustice."

If that is the price paid to get hundreds of other people off the government teat and stop subsidising the labour needs of you and your company, awesome. That high school kid misses out but his dad, who does more than press a button and generates more than ten times his pay packet for the company he labours for, gets to put food on the table.

This is not an unintended consequence at all.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday March 07, 2013 @09:14AM (#5337629)
A free market does not operate as a moral system. If you want to inject morals, price-fixing and wage-fixing are especially miserable ways to do it. The free market responds, often in ways you don't anticipate, and your social experiment goes weirdly sideways.
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @09:20AM (#5337654)
"A free market does not operate as a moral system."

I didn't bring morals into this, you'll notice the no-minimum-wage guy is the one that started bringing 'deserves' into this. I was talking about getting people off government support by making employers pay enough for workers to live on.

"If you want to inject morals, price-fixing and wage-fixing are especially miserable ways to do it."

Seems to work OK in a bunch of places.

"The free market responds, often in ways you don't anticipate, and your social experiment goes weirdly sideways."

The free market is a myth.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by crusso on Thursday March 07, 2013 @01:18PM (#5339164)
Seems to work OK in a bunch of places.

Most economists disagree vehemently with you.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @01:57PM (#5339412)
[Citation Needed]

Also, what do economists know? Where were they in the buildup to the '08 crash? Nowhere to be seen, that's where.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by crusso on Thursday March 07, 2013 @02:47PM (#5339721)
I guess economists are to blame because you weren't paying attention and you can't even be bothered to use Google to educate yourself.

http://nicedeb.wordpress.com/2008/09/21/the-white-house-warn...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cMnSp4qEXNM

Economists were warning of the housing bubble from the beginning of the decade. Republicans were warning of the problems with fannie/freddie from as early as 2002.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by daniel-cussen on Friday March 08, 2013 @08:43AM (#5343348)
This is the closest to the right margin I've ever seen a discussion go.
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by nathan_long on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:32AM (#5337469)
"Oversupply" is the key word there.

How much do I value having clean water? A lot. I'd pay $100 a gallon if I had to do so to survive.

But I'm happily paying a tiny fraction of that and "pocketing the difference". That's because my demand is easily met by the supply.

Am I wronging the water company? Of course not. If they want to make more, they have to offer me something I can't get from someone else for cheaper.

Not to mention the fact that "pocketing the difference" in both cases actually means "spending the difference on something else."

EDIT:

I'm not allowed to reply to the next reply to me, but there is a difference between treating humans as a commodity and treating their labor as a commodity.

I have a right not to be enslaved. I do not have a right to be paid for my labor AT ALL, much less to be paid a certain amount. I have to compete to sell my labor to the highest bidder, just as though I were selling widgets.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @10:42AM (#5338212)
"I'm not allowed to reply to the next reply to me"

You can usually hit 'link' and it'll let you reply in there, not sure if that's always the case.

"I do not have a right to be paid for my labor AT ALL, much less to be paid a certain amount. I have to compete to sell my labor to the highest bidder, just as though I were selling widgets."

You talk about these things as if they were written in stone somewhere. When you start to look at this in terms of absolute rights you lose sight of the point to some extent - what outcome do we want here? How can this best be achieved? What are the downsides?

The people who are stuck on minimum wage are the least able to compete. They have no skills and likely some difficulty acquiring them, they probably lack the ability to negotiate, they don't have the choice of not taking work because the alternative is starvation. The logical conclusion for them, were a truly free and unregulated market for labour ever to appear, would be contracting their lives away for a roof and some food, working insane hours in hazardous conditions for little to nothing.

Make no mistake here, a proportion of the population cannot better themselves.

Over the last hundred or so years we've added a huge framework of workers rights to our society to stop this very situation. A minimum wage is part of this, and raising it may well help large numbers of people.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:36AM (#5337485)
Absolutely, oversupply is the word.

However society is built by and for human beings, not machines or economic ideals. Where water is a commodity, treating humans as one must have limits, surely?

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by twoodfin on Thursday March 07, 2013 @07:44AM (#5337298)
I don't get it. Do the same arguments apply to, say, subsidized college tuition?
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:20AM (#5337411)
I'm not sure I see how that applies to subsidised tuition, could you elaborate?
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by twoodfin on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:42AM (#5337504)
Whenever a college charges more money than a student can pay, that student has to seek financial aid, which is subsidized by the taxpayer.

Do colleges have a "broken business model", too?

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:50AM (#5337526)
You could say that yes. But you could also say it's in our collective interest to help students achieve a higher level of education, and therefore we could/should choose to support this broken model.

You could make the claim that it's in our collective interest to keep WalMart profitable, but it would be something of a harder sell. IMHO.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by twoodfin on Thursday March 07, 2013 @10:33AM (#5338156)
What about food aid? Are the evil food conglomerates "taking money out of our pockets" by charging prices that some people can't afford and thus requiring a government subsidy?

Your theory that by democratically choosing to subsidize something, the government is creating an obligation on the part of private business to make the subsidy unnecessary is bizarre.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @10:59AM (#5338306)
"Are the evil food conglomerates "taking money out of our pockets" by charging prices that some people can't afford and thus requiring a government subsidy?"

Who said anything about evil? I merely think that the labour market does not resemble anything like a free market (nor can it or should it), and at the moment employers are profiting handsomely while depending on the public purse.

"Your theory that by democratically choosing to subsidize something, the government is creating an obligation on the part of private business to make the subsidy unnecessary is bizarre."

I'm not sure that's my theory at all. My 'theory' is that income top-ups via food stamps, tax credits, whatever, where someone is employed, form an unofficial subsidy to employers, and one that I think we should be trying to find ways to eliminate. If one of the ways we choose to do that is by pushing more responsibility onto the employer, then I'm not sure I see a problem.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by twoodfin on Thursday March 07, 2013 @12:01PM (#5338671)
income top-ups via food stamps, tax credits, whatever, where someone is employed, form an unofficial subsidy to employers

Spell that out for me. When I hire Bob at $8/hour, what difference does it make to me whether the government is giving him a tax credit for being poor, or owning a home, or buying an electric car?

How am I being "subsidized"?

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @12:09PM (#5338728)
Bob can't feed himself or his kids on that, so I have to reach into my pocket (taxes) to help him out. If I didn't do that, Bob and his kids would either slowly starve to death or move somewhere else. Either way, no more employee for you.

There is your subsidy.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by twoodfin on Thursday March 07, 2013 @12:17PM (#5338776)
Why is it my responsibility to make up the difference, and not the McDonald's across the street that didn't hire him at all? Or the landlord who is charging Bob $400/month instead of $300/month?

What you're saying is perhaps rhetorically appealing, but it doesn't make sense.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @12:44PM (#5338959)
Why is it my responsibility to make up the difference

Because I'm sick of doing it for you, when I have nothing to do with your business.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by twoodfin on Thursday March 07, 2013 @01:09PM (#5339108)
You could at least attempt to explain why all the other people who receive the benefits of your generosity towards Bob aren't equally responsible. If Bob starves to death, his landlord loses a tenant. His grocer loses a customer, etc. What makes his employer special?
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Thursday March 07, 2013 @02:03PM (#5339447)
The others are more subject to market pressures. Take a look all over this thread for some really well-cited explanations of exactly why employment is not like these other things.
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by twoodfin on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:42PM (#5341653)
Or you could just tell me.
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Nursie on Friday March 08, 2013 @05:05AM (#5342740)
Or you could use your eyes and read.
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by smsm42 on Thursday March 07, 2013 @03:26PM (#5339968)
Walmart has no say in the decision of who is getting food stamps. So if you, as a voter, decide that somebody has to get food stamps - Walmart can not be responsible for that decision. In any case, thinking that without Walmart salary the people that now getting food stamps wouldn't get them is clearly fallacious. Walmart is a largest private employer in the country, and employs a lot of low-skills people. The people of the US decided that earnings that Walmart can provide to these low-skills workers are not enough for them and the people want to give these workers more money. How it's Walmart's fault? They'd get public assistance with or without Walmart - with Walmart they just needs less of it, but it's not up to Walmart to replace the welfare system the people of the US instituted.
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by sergiosgc on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @08:33PM (#5335366)
You wrongly assume the job market is a perfect market. It's not; there are barriers to entry, barriers to exit and lots of asymmetric negotiation positions.
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by crusso on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:20AM (#5337410)
Nobody said it's a perfect market. It's not a market dominated by monopolies either. The heavy handed solutions provided by minimum wages and other government measures doesn't help matters. They mask some problems while creating many others due to economic dislocation.

In the end, masterminds planning all our lives and trying to create utopia on earth have never done better than following simpler rules of law and letting people deal with each other in a free market capitalistic system.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by sergiosgc on Thursday March 07, 2013 @08:31AM (#5337464)
Sorry, the GP reasoning assumes a perfect market, when stating that people are free to choose another employer if the current one is not paying enough. What wasn't stated in my comment is that the market is not perfect because of monopolistic behaviour. You kick off your argument with two misinterpretations of my comment and the GP's.

The market is illiquid, for example, because of exit/entry costs associated with relocation, such as selling your home at underwater values. This is one example of the factors I mentioned. Others abound.

The utopia/mastermind argument falls flat when you consider whether the US model is ahead of social-democrat states such as Denmark or Sweden. A cursory look at stats such as infant mortality rates or % of population below the poverty line strongly suggests the "mastermind" model is better.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by crusso on Thursday March 07, 2013 @09:07AM (#5337588)
* The utopia/mastermind argument falls flat when you consider whether the US model is ahead of social-democrat states such as Denmark or Sweden*

If we're doing a comparison, we need to compare across other utopian states. You need to throw in Greece, Italy, Portugal, the Soviet Union, North Korea, etc. You don't just get to cherry pick a couple of the few reasonable successes on your side of the ledger.

Furthermore, you have to realize that there's a memetic/genetic difference in Denmark vs the US. We can no more adopt the rules and policies of Denmark here than the US can impose its style of democracy on Afghanistan.

Finally, I would argue that countries like Denmark receive an amazing amount of benefit from other countries like the United States which provide most of the defense and technological advances that give them a cozy safe environment in which they get to spend most of their money on social programs.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by sergiosgc on Thursday March 07, 2013 @11:25AM (#5338457)
I'll take the bait on the three states you mention that are indeed stable democracies following a social-democrat strategy: Greece, Italy and Portugal. I'll drop the Soviet Union and North Korea, which are straw men in your argument, for plainly obvious reasons.

Let's back our conversation with numbers, shall we? Infant mortality rates and percent of population below the poverty line.

Infant mortality rates (deaths by 1000 live births)[1,4]: United States 6.81, Greece 4.65, Italy 3.51, Portugal 4.45, EU 4.49

% of population below poverty line [2,3]: United States 15.1%, Greece 20%, Portugal 18%, Italy 18,2%

So, I think we can close the discussion on infant mortality rates. It'd be a stretch proving that the US is better than Greece with those numbers.

As for the poverty threshold, I could argue that the numbers are within the same order of magnitude, but I don't really have to. Some statistics gimmicks are occurring here: The US poverty line is defined at an annual income of around $11k, for a median national income of around $50k. The EU defines the poverty line at percentile 40% of national income. Easily any of the European countries has one order of magnitude less poor people than the US.

You brought up indicators on innovation and defence spending. As for defence, it's an endless discussion, where I guarantee you, many people in the world would wave away US military intervention outside of its own borders in a heartbeat. Innovation is a more interesting topic, since it's often touted as a bastion of the US. Here, the sheer scale of the US is misleading. Try to compare with aggregates of the same dimension, like the EU: http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/policies/innovation/files/ius... You'll find that the US/Japan do lead, but nowhere can they be defined as the world providers of R&D, from where other countries benefit.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mor... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_percentage... [3] http://www.inequalitywatch.eu/spip.php?article99 [4] http://www.indexmundi.com/european_union/infant_mortality_ra...

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by pixl97 on Thursday March 07, 2013 @12:00PM (#5338657)
Birth rate is a bad number to look at because it's not taking in purely economic effects, it's racial and historical effects.

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db09.htm#arethere

http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s0080.p...

Had America not been founded on slavery and a history of inequality afterwards our numbers would be much closer to the EU stats.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @06:59PM (#5334943)
Unless Walmart is in control of all jobs in the market or unless Walmart and other employers are illegally colluding by sticking to a low wage agreement - the value of productivity per hour is what workers at Walmart are negotiating.

That is ludicrously utopian thinking. Reality does not conform to theory, there is always some gap between productivity and wages. Oh hell, it's been a growing gap, for the past 40 years.

By eliminating jobs through manipulating the minimum wage so thoughtlessly, you would destroy vital segments of the job market that serve a purpose.

No, I ensure that jobs go to people who actually need them. Besides, teenagers earning spending money can shovel snow off the books, or any number of other small jobs that they already do without recourse to an official employment contract.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by danenania on Thursday March 07, 2013 @06:33AM (#5337145)
Of course there's a gap between productivity and wages. It's called profit. If a company doesn't make some profit off an employee's endeavors, why would they hire him/her?

And if this gap, as you call it, is too high for the American workforce in general, for millions and millions of people, it would mean there is tremendous money to be made by companies willing to pay higher and so capture a portion of this surplus.

The real reason that Americans are so exploited economically is because they lack the ability to reason about economics and are easily fooled by fallacious claims that benefit the most powerful at their own expense. The minimum wage is just a minor example among countless schemes designed to make the poor, working, middle, and even upper middle classes feel they are being aided by government policies while they are actually being copiously robbed in broad daylight.