News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by lifeisstillgood on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @04:43PM (#5334189)
I seem unable to reply to others in this thread but I would like to take a view on the two comments that frame this : basically let's raise the minimum wage to $35 or to $1000 / hour.

Now we should reasonably assume that there will not suddenly be an increase in jobs that can afford to pay 35 (or 1000!) - so those jobs will remain steady roughly. And those jobs below will either vanish or will find they can employ peoe at those rates.

So there will be an increase in unemployment.

But that's not the point - we are seeing a massive structural shift in jobs - technology is displacing at the White collar middle skill level. There are going to be less jobs no matter what.

The share of GDP captured by wages is the important measure here - not the individual wage rate but using employment as a means of distributing wealth how do we spread the wealth around.

If half the jobs vanish then we may simply find a social balance in women staying at home and men earning double.

(nb I am not advocating this back-to-the-50s as a social good, just that minimum wage increases do not have to mean the share of the wealth diopps - we just need to find ways to share it out that we as society think are equitable)

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by Symmetry on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @04:56PM (#5334288)
Technology has been replacing workers since the tractor was introduced around 1900. But unemployment hasn't kept going up because we keep finding new ways to employ people.

But if by some miracle we do finally automate everything minimum wages won't help at all - we're talking about a situation where there's no reason to employ someone in the first place. In that case just tax production and provide everyone a guaranteed minimum income. No need to worry about work disincentives, they weren't working anyways!

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by lifeisstillgood on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @05:13PM (#5334387)
Maybe. I don't have a good answer for how to equitably distribute the 40% or so of GDP that is currently captured by wage packets.

Maybe Sweden will take your approach, but I would be amazed if the US will :-). But some solution will be needed.

Re:Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift mini... by pixl97 on Thursday March 07, 2013 @12:31PM (#5338866)
>But if by some miracle we do finally automate everything

or

If we quit finding new ways new ways to employ people...

You don't have to automate everything, just increase unemployment to a significant enough percentage and social instability (rioting, political unrest) will be the primary concern.