He may very well have been a poor worker, but it strikes me as odd how superficial our idea of a good worker is. Productivity being equal (at home or work), what does it matter if he seems to be having it easy? The illusion of looking busy still carries a lot of weight apparently.
The things that made us think he wasn't productive were: 1.) when he emailed the company saying he was sick and then show up at the company party later that day (more than once); 2.) his solicitation of others to watch non-work-related videos with him during business hours; 3.) his inability to face up to the fact he was soliciting others to watch non-work-related videos with him during business hours.
Often that isn't work. The problem here sounds managerial to me - that perhaps Yahoo's management can't tell good work from bad work so they fall back on vanity metrics like "butt time in seat."
> He should have been fired.
If he was getting his work done, what does it matter? This response reeks of 'if I can't see him working, he isn't working.'
I neglected to mention that the company eventually decided to make it a policy to not email the entire company about working from home. This made him much more tolerable. :-)
That said, maybe telecommuting was the problem here. But in any case, it bears some thinking about. There must be some people whose behavior would be better if they had to come into the office. Conversely, there must be some people who behave better if they get to work remotely. Not sure which category your guy falls into, but like you say, maybe people preferred him at a distance.
That was fine and all, but then he would send emails about how he wasn't feeling well and was going stay at home, then show up for the after-hours company parties. He once sent an all-company email to invite others to watch videos with him in one of the meeting rooms during a Wednesday afternoon. I responded "Wednesday afternoon? I think I'll be at my day job then." To which he replied "By Wednesday afternoon, I meant after 6pm. Technically, that is afternoon."
My manager tallied up the days that he did this, and I forget the exact number, but they added up to more than 50 work days in 10 months. The policy wasn't specific about how many days you could work from home, so he was allowed to do this. Worse, others started to follow his example.
And yet, he was getting his work done on those days off, so no one fired him. But, his behavior annoyed everyone s.t. we called working at home "Smithing". I still showed up at work and put in my best, but it certainly was demoralizing to have to work with such douchebaggery.