Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone?
by rayiner on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @03:56PM
(#5327293)
You're bringing unrelated issues into the discussion. The point isn't that transfer payments have zero impact. The point is that transfer payments have less of an economic impact than than, say, using the money to blow up things in Iraq. So just looking at federal spending as a whole isn't a great way to measure the economic impact of government--you have to dig down and see where the money is going.
Another way to look at it is: consider two governments, both spend 30% of GDP. The first spends 25% on bureaucracy and the military, and 5% on transfer payments, while the second spends 10% of bureaucracy and the military, and 15% of transfer payments. Which government probably has a lower economic impact? Which government probably has more "fat" to trim?
Another way to look at it is: consider two governments, both spend 30% of GDP. The first spends 25% on bureaucracy and the military, and 5% on transfer payments, while the second spends 10% of bureaucracy and the military, and 15% of transfer payments. Which government probably has a lower economic impact? Which government probably has more "fat" to trim?