Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by asafira on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @11:21PM
(#5329294)
As a physics grad student, I wanted to mention that graphene _was_ a buzz-word a few years ago. It's popularity has since died significantly in the community. It's still around, but nowhere near as popular as it used to be. Maybe the same will happen in popular science?
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by dhughes on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @06:51PM
(#5328305)
Yes the graphene covered DVD put in a LightScribe DVD drive made a supercapacitor I'm sure that knowledge may someone help in making better batteries (yes I know a capacitor isn't a battery).
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by solistice on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @03:12PM
(#5333506)
But a battery is a capacitor. Well, technically not, but they behave similarily, with the battery storing more energy per cubic centimeter than the capacitor, at the trade off of having a much higher internal resistance. Also I believe he meant data storage, since we have battery technologies which would work for this application, even though more juice is always a juicy prospect.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by short_circut on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @03:20PM
(#5327058)
I find claims of such to be somewhat questionable. Even if we could enable Terabit speeds over wireless it does not good if the hardware receiving it is incapable of handling that much data in that short of time. I mean we get max hard drive write speeds of 3.0 GB/s for the average user. Ram and CPU are still on the order of Ghz. We may be able to cram that much in the air but it does no good if the computers can't handle it.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by freehunter on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @03:30PM
(#5327119)
It's a fair point. It's the same bottlenecking issue that plagues mobile devices. We can make multi-core and multi-ghz processors with giant, bright, high resolution displays, but we're having a hard time getting battery technology to keep up with this immense power draw.
The good news is, with these restraints being placed on improvements in technology, it gives incentive to further invest in research to making better batteries or faster storage devices.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by solistice on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @04:14PM
(#5327389)
There's a graphene for that too. Or rather graphene supercapacitors, which for their size and thickness are remarkable. They'll likely be a tease for a couple of years, move into specialized products like pacemakers and then slowly flow into the consumer market, just like Li-Ion batteries did, Light Emitting Diodes and Transistors. R&D, why do you torture me so, showing me powerful technology I could design sexy things with, due in a couple of years?
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by ktsmith on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @03:29PM
(#5327111)
So should these researchers sit on their hands until such time as hardware capable of utilizing those transfer rates exist? The mathematical modeling here is at the very least useful in determining this is a path worth exploring with prototypes.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by hosh on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @04:17PM
(#5327404)
Yeah. But that is already incredibly useful. When assembling electronic components from a number of suppliers, you would not have to wire them up into a circuit board. You only need to physically put them close to each other and then configure them to talk to each other.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by hosh on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @04:15PM
(#5327392)
I remember John Scalzi's Old Man's War universe where the human electronic tech was based on microchip modules communicating to each other wirelessly. There are no wires. I just never expected to see people developing such technology a few years after I read that.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by nb13 on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @05:15PM
(#5327760)
Well, the article says they've only drawn up blueprints of how the technology could work so far. I hope they start actually developing this soon though.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by ripperdoc on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @08:18PM
(#5328684)
This is indeed interesting, but I'd say far beyond the needs. 10Gbps wireless transfer already exists (e.g. http://www.engadget.com/2013/02/27/ntt-docomo-confirms-succe... ), and that is beyond what flash based memory can do. In any case, it would mean transferring a BluRay in something like 30 seconds, assuming you had a faster drive.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by InclinedPlane on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @08:46PM
(#5328776)
Don't be so quick. Don't just consider single link transfers, remember that wireless is always shared bandwidth. If you have a terabit for everyone that means you can have hundreds of megabits for tens of thousands of folks in a small area all connected to one access point / cell tower.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by trotsky on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @10:17PM
(#5329115)
Water vapor in these bands is a strong absorber limiting distance in earth's atmosphere to ~10 meters or less. Subtract a good deal for omnidirectional emissions and decent snr.
Water and water vapor has the same effect on the visual part of the spectrum also, but this doesn't reduce people's enthusiasm for it as a potential communications medium.
Re:Graphene Antennas Would Enable Terabit Wireless Downloads
by femto on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @06:41PM
(#5328261)
Odd, given that the log-periodic antenna is fractal and invented around 50 years ago (1957 by Duhamel and Isbell?). I personally was working with such antennas in 1992. They're not called fractal, since their invention predates the invention of the work "fractal" in 1975, by Mandelbrot.
The owners of the patent actually acknowledge the above in a FAQ on their site [2]. It's accompanied by an unconvincing justification for why they claim to own fractal antennas.
https://www.sciencemag.org/content/335/6074/1326.ful
The good news is, with these restraints being placed on improvements in technology, it gives incentive to further invest in research to making better batteries or faster storage devices.
"640k of memory should be enough for anybody"
I didn't mean to imply this use would be unimportant. This could be huge.
If this argument had merit, light would be unsuitable for long-distance communication.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/d/db/Atm...
Water and water vapor has the same effect on the visual part of the spectrum also, but this doesn't reduce people's enthusiasm for it as a potential communications medium.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terahertz_radiation
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Log-periodic_antenna
--- Edit:
The owners of the patent actually acknowledge the above in a FAQ on their site [2]. It's accompanied by an unconvincing justification for why they claim to own fractal antennas.
[2] http://www.fractenna.com/nca_faq.html