News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by crusso on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @09:38AM (#5324663)
Oh, I hope you appreciate the complete contradiction in your arguments.

I made a statement in support of Federalism as a basis for our founding. You said:

This is middle school civics drivel

Then later you said:

I think federalism is a failed experiment and I have no interest in re-litigating the Civil War.

So apparently, Federalism was a core part of the "experiment" of or Founding and not "middle school civics drivel".

Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by rayiner on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @11:10AM (#5325266)
The statement which I called drivel was: "The Founding Fathers were deeply paranoid of an overbearing government and an very powerful political class." The Founders were not a homogenous group of people, and the dominant faction, the Federalists, looked quite admiringly at the British Parliament.

> Federalism was a core part of the "experiment"

I didn't say Federalism wasn't a part of the experiment of the Founding. I'm addressing your historical revisionism about why the Federal system exists. It has more to do with political expediency in a climate where the states held all the cards than any deeply held belief that the Federal government should be as strong as possible.

Remember, the Framers didn't have a mandate to create a new Constitution, because the state legislatures were worried what that would do to their power. They created the Constitution they thought they could get away with.