Hats off to you guys, like the semantic query style rather than the traditional mould!
In fact, thinking about it more, I strongly suspect that personality (in a Myers-Briggs J/P way) has a lot to do with how we prefer to travel. Some people plan everything out ahead of time down to the hour, some people close their eyes and spin the globe.
I think the other factor is how often you fly. If you don't travel/vacation very often, you are more likely to be travelling for a specific reason where dates and destination is known. If you travel very often, you will probably have more opportunities to pick a random place to go for the weekend.
(I'm the co-founder)
It does however suggest I walk across water to start with (there is a bus stop further distance wise that doesn't involve this that I usually take): http://i.imgur.com/FxhVhxj.png
I'm pretty much the same if I'm going on holiday - I usually chose an exact city well before looking for flights rather than a country or an area.
If I'm flying back to my parents though, it's a bit different. There are a number of airports around them:
- one has flights daily but requires a 3 hour train journey
- another has flights twice a week and is a 1 hour drive
- another has flights daily, is a 1 hour drive, but is usually more than twice the price of the others
- another has flights daily, is a 2 hour drive, and the price varies
For this I usually just open SkyScanner (Adioso doesn't seem to have many low cost airlines in Europe) in 10 tabs or so and compare the results myself...