Having PG as a commenter, mod, and admin is a tremendous asset. HN also benefits from the close ties to YC in general--it'd be a bit tricky to tell all the YC folks that they need to post not on news.ycombinator.com but over at reddit.com/r/therealhackernews or whatever.
Re:Show HN: Submit your ideas for improving HN
by phillmv on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:55PM
(#5322389)
HN doesn't benefit from close ties to YC. YC benefits from close ties to HN.
YC folks will post to whatever is considered the de rigeur nerd/startup news site, which over the last couple of years has become HN - having migrated from reddit (and slashdot, before).
There will be another one, in due time.
Re:Show HN: Submit your ideas for improving HN
by miguelrochefort on Monday March 04, 2013 @10:02PM
(#5322605)
PG could do all those things on Reddit. YC folks could do all those things on Reddit. Just redirect news.ycombinator.com to reddit.com/r/hn2 and that's it.
Re:Show HN: Submit your ideas for improving HN
by sgdesign on Monday March 04, 2013 @09:10PM
(#5322436)
I'm not against of migrating to a "better" HN when the time has come, but I doubt it will be Reddit.
I think it'll instead be something built from the ground up specifically for this community that serves its needs better than HN currently does.
That being said, as someone who's working on this very thing I can say that developing a "Better HN" is far from easy…
If you want another example, just look at Discourse (http://discourse.org). I think it took them one year with a 5 or 6-people team to get there, and I didn't see anybody jumping ship from HN to a Discourse implementation yet.
I'm sure it would be easier to convince Reddit to let subreddits behave like HN than trying to keep HN up to date with the modern world.
Just my two cents.