News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by mikeash on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:55PM (#5322156)
What is the supposed rationale for Japanese internment being a good idea? Was it the supposed danger to the Japanese themselves from retribution? Why didn't that happen elsewhere, where they were not interned, if so? Was it the risk that Axis sympathizers would sabotage the war effort? If so, why did this never happen in Hawaii, which was so full of Japanese-descended Americans that internment simply could not be done?
Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by sp332 on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:00PM (#5322182)
The specific point that I recall was that it was impossible to ask Japanese living in America to deny one of their countries and adhere completely to the other. They were both Japanese and American and would therefore be hopelessly compromised if they had to pick a side.
Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by venus on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:12PM (#5322240)
Sort of makes me wish America would declare war on the Philippines. Be sure to visit Malkin in her camp after a few years to ask for her updated opinion on the matter! After all, it would be impossible to ask her to deny one of her countries ...
Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by mpyne on Monday March 04, 2013 @10:54PM (#5322801)
The single-most decorated U.S. Army combat brigade during WWII was composed of Nisei Japanese-Americans. Even for the persons who actually immigrated from Japan, why else would they have come over if not because they saw something better? They can't all have been fifth columnists sent to blow up planes in hangars.

However a simpler response is to point out that we did not inter German-Americans, Italian-Americans, immigrants from Bulgaria or Romania, etc., despite there being a much less clear reasoning for war with the European Nazi powers.

Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by krichman on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @12:39AM (#5323124)
Actually, I think there was a book about this, like where people were arrested for thinking about crimes, something like that. Except a lot of those Japanese probably weren't even thinking it.
Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by mikeash on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:06PM (#5322201)
And yet, that was clearly not the case (e.g. the large Japanese population in Hawaii that was not "hopelessly compromised"), so that's a pretty bad justification.