Also, a little more far-fetched: if you don't mind doing a bit of page-scraping, you might consider letting people link hnwishlist accounts to their HN account. Just have a profile field for an HN account, and let people prove their ownership of an account by putting something like "hnwishlist username: $NAME" in their profile temporarily. Then you could do things like offering upvotes and downvotes using the same karma thresholds as HN.
The sign in box seems to break Firefox's ability to save the username and password.
When signed in, the "Change password", "My Account", and "Sign out" buttons have three different clashing visual styles.
Please consider adding downvotes; for instance, I'd like to downvote ideas like http://hnwishlist.com/posts/ae15555a-f3c1-43f3-8a80-cef2a22e... or http://hnwishlist.com/posts/54520ba4-f32e-473a-8590-365e893f...
Also, a little more far-fetched: if you don't mind doing a bit of page-scraping, you might consider letting people link hnwishlist accounts to their HN account. Just have a profile field for an HN account, and let people prove their ownership of an account by putting something like "hnwishlist username: $NAME" in their profile temporarily. Then you could do things like offering upvotes and downvotes using the same karma thresholds as HN.