I rather understood the original link to offer that dichotomy in the last sentence of the third paragraph: ‘Taking away features can be so much harder than adding features, but subtracting often creates the most value for your users.’. But, yes, your example is exactly what _should_ be done, but is often much harder to do than to ‘simply’ reduce everything to the simple UI.
Here is a simple UI:
http://whitemagicsoftware.com/software/climate/
Here is the same software, but with a "cluttered" UI:
http://whitemagicsoftware.com/software/climate/guru.shtml
It is entirely possible to make simple things simple while adding rich complexity for advanced users. It does, however, take more forethought and planning during development.