Re:How I spend my first 5 minutes on a server
by vidarh on Monday March 04, 2013 @04:50AM
(#5317500)
apt-get is most definitively not idempotent without a lot of care. It will upgrade packages if a new version is available, and such upgrades can have widespread implications.
Otherwise I agree with you - Puppet/ Chef etc. are overly big on ceremony for me. We "only" use about 100 VM's on about 20 physical servers at the moment, so it's a "simple" setup.
I think where people get the most value out of systems like Puppet and Chef is if a lot of their servers or VM's have simple enough requirements that they can largely use "off the shelf" community provided configurations. The more customisation you need, the more the leve of ceremony starts biting you. The more you can rely on ready-made scripts, the more those apps help you because of the size of their communities.
Otherwise I agree with you - Puppet/ Chef etc. are overly big on ceremony for me. We "only" use about 100 VM's on about 20 physical servers at the moment, so it's a "simple" setup.
I think where people get the most value out of systems like Puppet and Chef is if a lot of their servers or VM's have simple enough requirements that they can largely use "off the shelf" community provided configurations. The more customisation you need, the more the leve of ceremony starts biting you. The more you can rely on ready-made scripts, the more those apps help you because of the size of their communities.