News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Map Shows Where 220mph Trains Would Go in the U.S. by rayiner on Sunday March 03, 2013 @08:15PM (#5315934)
The idea that in 20 years we'll have self-driving cars on any substantial scale is totally ridiculous. If I had to bet money, we won't even have a substantial electric car deployment by then, much less self-driving cars.

Also: the physics of high-speed cars makes the concept of cars traveling as fast as bullet trains totally ridiculous. The fact that a car is self-driving doesn't change the physics of tire/road friction.

Re:Map Shows Where 220mph Trains Would Go in the U.S. by uvdiv on Sunday March 03, 2013 @08:17PM (#5315942)
Also: the physics of high-speed cars makes the concept of cars traveling as fast as bullet trains totally ridiculous. The fact that a car is self-driving doesn't change the physics of tire/road friction.

Friction losses aren't significant. These cars are limited by aerodynamic drag power -- this scales as speed^3, and dominates all other losses.

Re:Map Shows Where 220mph Trains Would Go in the U.S. by jellicle on Sunday March 03, 2013 @08:57PM (#5316091)
Friction losses aren't significant. These cars are limited by aerodynamic drag power -- this scales as speed^3, and dominates all other losses.

No.

"Of the energy output of fuel in a car engine, 33% is spent in exhaust, 29% in cooling and 38% in mechanical energy, of which friction losses account for 33% and air resistance for 5%. By comparison, an electric car has only half the friction loss of that of a car with a conventional internal combustion engine."

So, meh, even if magic self-driving cars had zero air resistance, they're only 5% more efficient than non-self-driving cars.

Re:Map Shows Where 220mph Trains Would Go in the U.S. by uvdiv on Sunday March 03, 2013 @09:18PM (#5316180)
These cars are limited by aerodynamic drag power...

I mean future self-driving cars travelling at bullet-train speeds. For these, losses are dominated by drag.

Re:Map Shows Where 220mph Trains Would Go in the U.S. by newbie12 on Sunday March 03, 2013 @08:53PM (#5316068)
The auto industry is saying that fully self-driving cars will be on the market in ten years. The safety and entertainment benefits are enormous. Bullet trains require an entirely new track infrastructure, whereas self driving cars are an obvious upgrade to the existing auto infrastructure (which is already 1000x more popular than rail).
Re:Map Shows Where 220mph Trains Would Go in the U.S. by jarcoal on Sunday March 03, 2013 @08:21PM (#5315956)
I won't argue that 2030 will be the magic year, but self-driving is a far greater incentive for most people than being electric powered.
Re:Map Shows Where 220mph Trains Would Go in the U.S. by uvdiv on Sunday March 03, 2013 @08:36PM (#5316016)
You'll get both, because they're complementary. Self-driving cars will cut the economic cost of electric vehicles: autotaxis will replace private ownership, and their high upfront costs will be split between many users [1]. Conversely, self-driving cars will push performance envelopes, so the EV's enormous efficiency advantage will be desirable.

[1] The economics DO NOT work this way yet, because batteries degrade too quickly (Tesla is what, 500 charge-discharge cycles?). Heavier use means proportionally shorter life; no advantage. Solve battery life, and you've solved economics.

Re:Map Shows Where 220mph Trains Would Go in the U.S. by danielweber on Sunday March 03, 2013 @11:07PM (#5316529)
Yeah, you have to come up with external reasons (NB: they aren't necessarily bad reasons) to want an electric car. But self-driving cars have very obvious advantages that you don't need to explain anything about climate change or geopolitics to want.

I could reclaim about $1000 a week in billable time with a self-driving car (if I billed hourly, which I don't, but I think you get my point).

Re:Map Shows Where 220mph Trains Would Go in the U.S. by waterlesscloud on Sunday March 03, 2013 @08:38PM (#5316020)
We'll certainly have electric cars on a substantial scale by 2033, and it's likely we'll have self-driving cars deployed in some significant contexts (long distance freeway travel) by then.

Social forces will drive the former, economic forces will drive the latter.