Railroad trains are very energy-efficient, compared to cars driving along a road, or even trucks driving along a road. And if we suddenly had self-driving cars, packed close together and safer than the existing system, trains would still be more efficient.
The link below shows a table of transportation methods and efficiencies -- it shows railroad trains beating even motorcycles for efficiency.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_efficiency_in_transporta...
And if the government is involved, forget about it. It will be a massive mess of cost overruns and other financial shenanigans. And Amtrak proves that the government can't even run a railroad, let alone build one.
You know, the way a company would do it.
Yglesias wrote up this exact argument this week [1]. The Northeast Corridor profit he dug up [2] amounts to all of $136 million/year for the Northeast Corridor; a proposed upgrade is estimated at $151 billion [3]. (And the profit figure only includes operating costs -- the actually relevant figures aren't available).
[1] http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/03/01/amtrak_profit...
[2] http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/Research/Files/Reports/2013...
Holding infrastructure development hostage to starry-eyed visions of what we might have in the future is just foolish. The fundamental building blocks of society--power, water, transit, etc, have been pretty much unchanged since the 1960's. It's unlikely that they will do so in a dramatic way by the time HSR gets built.
Or Dubai in 17: http://www.ebaumsworld.com/pictures/view/187773/
Or (in the US): South (new) Las Vegas: http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=37228
Or take the 1994 LA Earthquake where the freeways were repaired 2.5 months early: http://articles.latimes.com/1994-04-06/news/mn-42778_1_santa...
Or you can even go 150 years back to when the London Sewage System was built, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_sewerage_system in a matter of a few years
Or Chongqing: http://forum.skyscraperpage.com/showthread.php?t=172962 ... their rivers glisten brown with progress (I guess)
Or take the Chinese High Speed Rail which went from 0 KM in 2007 to 9300 KM in 2012.
Or take the German Autobahn which went from 108 KM to 3736 KM between 1935 and 1940.
If the US doesn't sort this out it will have a significant impact in growth in the future. You can maybe see some of the effects of this already in the faster moving Internet infrastructure.
Infrastructure does not always move slowly. When it's time, it actually moves quite quickly.
These things run in cycles. The fact that infrastructure hasn't changed much since 1970 doesn't mean that infrastructure takes forever to change, it means that attention has been elsewhere since then.
Avedøre shows we can do 91% thermal and 49% electrical efficiency if we set our minds to it. But the fact is that most plants don't do better than 33% at both (because they're not that efficient and because they throw out all the heat).
Focus on the chart showing tons of greenhouse gas emissions per megawatt-hour. 1913 was still in a period of rapid technological development, but the curve necks around 1930. From 1930 to 2000, GHG emissions per megawatt hour dropped from around 1.5 tons/MWh to 1.0 tons/MWh.
This is what technological progress looks like. You have periods of rapid improvement followed by a plateau with extremely gradual improvements.
Why do you say copper wire is useles?
Also, w.r.t. the spaceship, what happens if the time between the tech for spaceship #1 and the tech for spaceship #2 includes an extinction-level event? Why build spaceship #2 when we can just wait another couple hundred years and assume that obviously we will improve it even more?
Why buy a new computer when it will be obsolete within a couple of months? I should just never buy a new computer and then I will never have to worry about it being obsolete!
The number I have seen quoted is that a train can move 1 ton 400 miles using 1 gallon of diesel.
Say that it finally becomes possible to reach a planet of a nearby star. It's a new technology that enables it, and we can build a spaceship that will support several generations of people during the trip. Maybe it takes 500 years to get there.
Well, 500 years is a long time. It's not as if our technological development will stop in the meantime. In fact, given 100 years of development, we might be able to construct a new ship that will only take 300 years to get to that planet. Which would mean it would overtake the first, and beat it by a hundred years.
In which case, why build the first ship at all?
That's the objection I've heard most recently against building high-speed rail in the united states. For instance, in the context of self-driving cars that might be able to organize themselves into "trains" on the road, or fit conditions where they would qualify for a higher speed limit, etc. While it may be true that we need high-speed rail now, is it going to be as true by the time they would actually get built?