News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Low-income students feel left out at Stanford by johnswamps on Tuesday March 24, 2009 @07:40PM (#531091)
Disclaimer: I am a grad student at Stanford (which definitely makes me low-income :) Undergrads whose families make under 60k go to Stanford for free and under 100k don't pay tuition. Yes there are some students who can afford a lot more than others, but I think Stanford does a pretty good job helping out low-income students. Obviously all schools could do a better job at attracting lower income applicants, but I don't know why they're singling out Stanford.
Re:Low-income students feel left out at Stanford by chris11 on Tuesday March 24, 2009 @10:11PM (#531273)
"I don't know why they're singling out Stanford."

Probably because they are one of the most selective universities in the area. Stanford accepts less than 10% of applicants a year. That is in the same range of any ivy league school. So Stanford is a leader in higher education. When Harvard decided to give need based financial aid to every family who made $180k or less a year, other colleges began discussions on revamping financial aid. Harvard became an example. So if Stanford changes, other schools will take notice.

Other Colleges react to Harvard's Financial Aid Plan:http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/12...

Re:Low-income students feel left out at Stanford by mlinsey on Tuesday March 24, 2009 @07:46PM (#531103)
I don't know why they're singling out Stanford.

Probably just because it's the SF Gate (same reason the only comparison made was to Berkeley).

Re:Low-income students feel left out at Stanford by gleb on Tuesday March 24, 2009 @09:16PM (#531216)
With articles like these, it's no surprise that Chronicle is going out of business. I was a low-income student in Staford, this article is a curious mix of misleading and plain wrong. I know that time is ripe for class warfare, but come on.

* Financial aid does not cover housing during the summer because Stanford undergrad is not in session during the summer

* Seeing how Stanford covers tuition and all the expenses for low-income students it's actually cheaper to go to Stanford than to stay at home. It's vastly harder for middle-income families to afford full cost of Stanford, than it is for low-income. Welcome to the modern elite college price discrimination/income redistribution.

* having a car for an undergrad is unnecessary and uncommon in Stanford (it's a large and self-sufficient campus), it's a luxury or cost of doing business if you have an off-campus job.

* there are good opportunities for low-income students got make a little extra money. Taking out a bit more in federally subsidized loans (reasonable if you expect your income to increase past college) and subsidized on-campus jobs which pay more than most post-undergraduate starting salaries would be good options.

* so on, so on ...

The lower-than-Berkeley Pell grant percentage is interesting. In addition to irrational belief that Stanford is "school for rich kids" I'd also point to the following rational reasons:

* Stanford is more selective. You get drastically fewer poor kids as you move to the right of the bell curve.

* Stanford practices affirmative action based on race. Berkeley is prohibited by law from using race and does it based on socio-economic status. Meaning that relatively to Berkeley Stanford discriminates against poor kids to free up space for protected minorities.

Re:Low-income students feel left out at Stanford by tokenadult on Tuesday March 24, 2009 @09:27PM (#531233)
I was a low-income student in Staford

What is the defining range of "low-income student" in this statement of yours, and in your several other comments in which you refer to other students? What is the boundary line between "low-income" and "middle-income" in your second bullet point?

Re:Low-income students feel left out at Stanford by gleb on Tuesday March 24, 2009 @09:44PM (#531245)
When I started college, somewhere around $30k family income I think, no assets. I would have qualified for the free ride under the current rules. We were recent immigrants, my parents' income rapidly went up during my junior/senior year, so I've seen both sides of the picture.
Re:Low-income students feel left out at Stanford by tokenadult on Tuesday March 24, 2009 @10:13PM (#531277)
I am a grad student at Stanford

What are typical graduate student stipends these days at Stanford? I have no idea.

Re:Low-income students feel left out at Stanford by endtime on Wednesday March 25, 2009 @02:15AM (#531528)
I'm a CS master's student at Stanford, which means I don't get funding automatically. But with a 20 hr/week assistantship (TA or RA) I get my tuition refunded, which is about $8200, and a roughly $7000 stipend. That's for one quarter (quarters are Sep-Dec, Jan-Mar, Apr-Jun). It's enough to cover housing, food, and a little extra...but it's certainly frugal living.
Re:Low-income students feel left out at Stanford by johnswamps on Tuesday March 24, 2009 @11:25PM (#531354)
In the sciences 20kish per nine months. Presumably a few thousand lower in the humanities, but I'm not sure. It's actually not that bad. The area is expensive and I can't afford a car, but it's enough to live comfortably.