Re:PHP has reached its limit
by krapp on Thursday February 28, 2013 @04:51PM
(#5301307)
PHP is not Java.
PHP is not Ruby.
PHP is not Python.
PHP is definitely not Perl.
Developers need to stop trying to force it to look and act like the languages they would rather be using. It doesn't have to be as ugly as Flow appears to be, at all, and in some PHP frameworks, it isn't. Because as has been mentioned already, comparing a framework with a framework is only valid when you pick the best framework, and as the Rubyists are fond of pointing out that Ruby Is Not Rails, well, PHP Is Not Flow. Nor is it Symfony or Yii or Laravel or Zend or the framework I'm building in my spare time which is still not quite as ugly as Flow. This article's argument is as arbitrary as it its conclusion is irrelevant.
The reasons PHP is not, and will not soon be, dead have to do with its ubiquity and utility in its one and only purpose -- preprocessing html. It does this perfectly adequately for many many use cases, provided you approach it like a donkey and not a horse. It is the animal that it is. Otherwise, you wind up with a swift kick in the shins. It's ugly, and ornery, and it stinks but it does its job and it's cheap and simple and it's not going away anytime soon.
Developers need to stop trying to force it to look and act like the languages they would rather be using. It doesn't have to be as ugly as Flow appears to be, at all, and in some PHP frameworks, it isn't. Because as has been mentioned already, comparing a framework with a framework is only valid when you pick the best framework, and as the Rubyists are fond of pointing out that Ruby Is Not Rails, well, PHP Is Not Flow. Nor is it Symfony or Yii or Laravel or Zend or the framework I'm building in my spare time which is still not quite as ugly as Flow. This article's argument is as arbitrary as it its conclusion is irrelevant.
The reasons PHP is not, and will not soon be, dead have to do with its ubiquity and utility in its one and only purpose -- preprocessing html. It does this perfectly adequately for many many use cases, provided you approach it like a donkey and not a horse. It is the animal that it is. Otherwise, you wind up with a swift kick in the shins. It's ugly, and ornery, and it stinks but it does its job and it's cheap and simple and it's not going away anytime soon.