News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @06:08PM (#5295680)
>Your description hardly sounds clean. In fact, given the complexity of business mergers, sales, taxes, etc., it sounds like it would result in an ever expanding nest of exemptions.

What does it have anything to do with taxes or any of that other stuff? If you have two corporate entities that merge, the merged entity can be considered the original assignee of all of the patents that each of the merging entities was. It's not a complicated rule. But it keeps trolls from setting up "mergers" to falsify their status as an "inventor or original assignee," because it's all or nothing. You couldn't transfer any subset of the selling entity's original patents to anyone else and still call them original patents.

Here, we can make it even more simple. Forget about mergers. You can transfer a patent for which you are the inventor or original assignee to another party and have that party be considered the original assignee if and only if you transfer every such patent you own to that party.

>There's nothing wrong with companies that buy IP and do nothing but licence it; that's how an efficient market in IP is likely to operate.

So say the patent trolls. It reminds me of what the high frequency traders say about liquidity: Even if it could theoretically be true under some set of artificial constraints, in practice the cost of allowing it pretty clearly exceeds the supposed efficiency benefits.

>The problem is with the frivolousness/obviousness of the original patents.

The problem is that software patents anyone is likely to infringe are inherently frivolous/obvious, because the lack of physical constraints causes there to be a million good ways to do any given thing in software, so (putting aside standards-essential patents that constitute their own special brand of unintended consequences), the only way you get a software patent that anyone else will ever infringe is to abstract the so-called invention out so far that it covers all plausible implementations rather than only the specific one that you're supposed to have invented.

The patent system wasn't designed for software. They're not compatible with one another. The proper solution is to eliminate software patents. But if we can't do that today then putting as many sensible limits on the amount of economic damage they can cause in the meantime will have to suffice.

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by jessriedel on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @07:34PM (#5296117)
> If you have two corporate entities that merge, the merged entity can be considered the original assignee of all of the patents that each of the merging entities was. It's not a complicated rule.

What about when companies spin-off subdivisions as separate companies? Can they "legitimately" own a patent and then spin-off a troll with that patent as its only asset?

Or what if the original inventor own only part of the company? How much do they need to own? If no minimum, then a troll will just sell 0.0001% of the company to the original patent holder. If a minimum, then the troll will find some other way to compensate the patent holder so they effectively doesn't cost them anything to hold that requisite amount.

Seriously, I know nothing about this stuff. I challenge you to find a someone well-versed in mergers and acquisitions who thinks a simple rule would work. Anytime you give property rights to someone but then try to restrict them, there will always be away to wriggle around the restrictions when sufficient money is at stake.

>So say the patent trolls. It reminds me of what the high frequency traders say about liquidity

I don't think your opinion about HFT is universally shared.

> The problem is that software patents anyone is likely to infringe are inherently frivolous/obvious...

I strongly disagree, but it would take us too far afield to debate it. Eliminating software patents might indeed be a good, crude decisions which is better than the status quo, but the abstract nature of software does not in principle prevent novel, patent-worthy ideas from being reliably identified.

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @11:27PM (#5296977)
>What about when companies spin-off subdivisions as separate companies? Can they "legitimately" own a patent and then spin-off a troll with that patent as its only asset?

Spin offs aren't mergers. If you create a new entity as a spin off and transfer patents to it, it wouldn't be the original assignee anymore, so it would have to practice the invention. A spin off that doesn't practice the invention is a patent troll.

>Or what if the original inventor own only part of the company?

It doesn't matter who owns the company, it matters who owns the patent. If it's owned entirely by either the inventors listed on the patent, or the first company they assigned the patent to immediately on issuance (typically their employer), then they wouldn't need to practice the invention. If it's anyone else then they would need to practice the invention. A company's single exclusive designated successor stands in for the original company if the original company ceases to exist. You can't split up the patents in any way or else all but the designated one of the new owner(s) will have to practice the invention.

> Anytime you give property rights to someone but then try to restrict them, there will always be away to wriggle around the restrictions when sufficient money is at stake.

Any time there is money on the table someone will try to take it. That's a poor argument for not doing anything about it.

>Eliminating software patents might indeed be a good, crude decisions which is better than the status quo, but the abstract nature of software does not in principle prevent novel, patent-worthy ideas from being reliably identified.

Software itself is an abstraction. The only types of patents that software could infringe are patents on mathematics itself (e.g. compression or crypto patents) or patents on abstract ideas that can be built on top of mathematical primitives, because that is all software is. It's abstractions built on abstractions built on abstractions built on mathematics. And none of that is even supposed to be patentable. Contrary to popular belief, patents aren't supposed to be granted for ideas, they're granted for inventions. An idea isn't an invention, the invention is the thing you make after you have an idea. You patent a nuclear reactor design, not E=mc^2.

The "problem" with software is that there are arbitrarily many practical inventions that implement a given idea. Patenting any partial subset of the possible implementations would be pointless, because any competent programmer could come up with a hundred other different ones that implement the same idea. But patenting the idea itself goes too far. Which is what they've been allowing and what causes all of these problems. It's why in software accidental infringement is the rule rather than the exception and as a consequence everything infringes everything.

People have intuitively understood this forever. It's for exactly this reason that literary works aren't patentable, because it would cause the exact same thing. But software makes peoples' brains explode because we created virtual worlds where you can go simulate human interaction and even buy and sell fake stuff for real money, and at some point we went from calling those interactive works of fiction names like World of Warcraft and Second Life and to calling them names like YouTube and Facebook and the App Store.

At some point we lost track of the line that distinguishes a patentable device that physically holds your CD collection from an unpatentable work of interactive fiction that allows you to see a picture of such a device on your screen and pretend to interact with it, and we started issuing patents for simulated "inventions" that exist solely as abstract ideas in software literary works. But it was never supposed to be this way because of exactly the mess that allowing that has caused.

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by makomk on Saturday March 02, 2013 @06:57PM (#5311727)
> Spin offs aren't mergers. If you create a new entity as a spin off and transfer patents to it, it wouldn't be the original assignee anymore, so it would have to practice the invention. A spin off that doesn't practice the invention is a patent troll.

Which would make ARM a patent troll - they're a spin-off of Acorn originally and they license designs to others rather than practicing their inventions themselves. I'm not sure you've entirely thought this through. (Probably not such a problem for ARM since all their Acorn-era patents have probably expired anyway, but the next similar company could really get screwed.)

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by rayiner on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @07:11PM (#5296017)
> It reminds me of what the high frequency traders say about liquidity: Even if it could theoretically be true under some set of artificial constraints, in practice the cost of allowing it pretty clearly exceeds the supposed efficiency benefits.

I don't get the ire against HFT. The only ones who should be worried about HFT besides regulators are the human traders who are going to be put out of work by HFT shops.

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @09:42PM (#5296638)
>I don't get the ire against HFT. The only ones who should be worried about HFT besides regulators are the human traders who are going to be put out of work by HFT shops.

I'm not convinced that HFT is anything particularly insidious, but the fig leaf of providing liquidity is pure rubbish and it seems like the sort of activity that shouldn't be rewarded with billions in profits. It reminds me of the scam from Office Space. Take a fraction of a penny from a large number of people and nobody really cares, but that doesn't mean you deserve the money. And it's causing an enormous amount of resources and brain power to go into beating the runner up by a fraction of a millisecond that could be going to something more productive.

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by rayiner on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @09:57PM (#5296690)
Why is the liquidity justification pure rubbish? That's what human traders do as well. HFT doesn't "take" money from anyone. Its all voluntary sales and purchases. They don't "deserve" it any more or less than any other middle man.
Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @11:57PM (#5297069)
>Why is the liquidity justification pure rubbish? That's what human traders do as well.

Human traders hold securities for more than fractions of a second. If I want to sell my shares of some low volume stock today and some other human investor wants to buy them next month, a third party who is willing to buy them from me today and sell them to the other buyer in a month is providing a useful service -- I get paid today, he gets the shares at a slight discount and makes a profit a month from now. That clearly doesn't apply when a high frequency trader buys shares and turns them around in fractions of a second.

>They don't "deserve" it any more or less than any other middle man.

A middle man deserves the profit he earns by providing value. What value is provided by a middle man engaged in naked arbitrage by taking advantage of an ephemeral information asymmetry?

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by tptacek on Thursday February 28, 2013 @11:59AM (#5299557)
There needs to be a name for the fallacy where people discuss trades as if prices could only move in one direction. That, obviously, is the only way you can frame a discussion of trading in terms of "discounts". In reality, an entity that takes a position in an instrument also bears the downside risk for that instrument. Averaged out, it is exactly as likely that an HFT shields an unwitting potential buyer from a loss as it is that they snipe away the profits from that sale.

The value provided by "middle men", be they robots or crooked traders in pits, is liquidity and price discovery. Trading allows people holding an instrument to unload it more quickly rather than waiting to convince themselves to take a bigger leap on pricing; it's what, in a simplifier Bohr-model kind of way of looking at stock trading, allows you to buy shares in a stock at a market price you can look up online as opposed to waiting for the stars to align. The faster the trading, the lower the spread, the smaller the leap sellers and buyers have to take.

It's worth noting again as always that before automated and program trading, spreads were higher, and the space in the spread between the bid and the ask was basically a license to steal.

Here's a good comment from awhile ago, including a cite to an accessible paper:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3895208

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by AnthonyMouse on Thursday February 28, 2013 @12:29PM (#5299712)
>Averaged out, it is exactly as likely that an HFT shields an unwitting potential buyer from a loss as it is that they snipe away the profits from that sale.

How can this be true consistent with HFT being profitable?

> The faster the trading, the lower the spread, the smaller the leap sellers and buyers have to take.

That's the theory. The issue is that when you get into sub-millisecond trades, you're so far into diminishing returns that the profits the HFTers are taking exceed the benefit of any theoretical increase in liquidity.

Also, the paper link in that post is truncated, but I found it on Google and (at least from the abstract) it doesn't seem to support what you're saying. The paper says HFT has caused spreads to go down because in order to mitigate its effects, third parties are breaking larger trades into smaller ones. But that only reduces the spread on paper by increasing the number of transactions.

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by tptacek on Thursday February 28, 2013 @01:20PM (#5300017)
HFT market makers profit from the spread the same way human market makers do. The difference is that HFT market makers narrow the spread sharply; they are fighting over a much smaller slice of the pie than humans do.

I'm not sure what you mean by your second point. Sellers and buyers are always breaking large blocks into small blocks. Moving large blocks of tradable instruments at the best price is one of the fundamental technical problems of trading. The spread captures what at any moment you would need to give to middlemen to transact on the market. Smaller is better no matter what the reason.

Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by wglb on Thursday February 28, 2013 @02:48PM (#5300525)
Large HFT players are market makers who are paid by exchanges to ALWAYS be in the market for each share traded.
Re:Politicians want “loser pays” rule for patent trolls by dllthomas on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @11:47PM (#5297046)
A fraction of a millisecond is a long time, in HFT.