News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Mz on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @05:33PM (#5295447)
As a woman who is willing to initiate, I find it rarely works. It mostly backfires. Men typically react one of two ways: "Cool! Slut throwing herself at me!" or "OMFG! Stalker!" It almost always goes disastrously. I have been working on figuring out how it works to attract a man and let him initiate. I find it to be rather tricky to navigate.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by marvin on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @05:58PM (#5295603)
What natrius said. Not meaning to sound mean here, I applaud your initiative. Really wish more girls had the balls to do the same. And there's probably a difference regarding how forward women and men are perceived (especially in the US, I don't get the same impression in Norway). But do you have any idea how many girls an average guy approaches for every one he actually has a mutual connection and attraction with?

In online dating, where I put in some effort (sending a serious, thought-out message and not just boilerplate) I get a reply to about one out of every five messages I send. The total track record after about a year of effort is one date per 20 women messaged, or something like that. The picture is better when you're meeting people at parties where you already have something in common (one in ten, maybe?) but I'm assuming the bar scene would be somewhere around 1/20 or worse. I'm in my mid twenties.

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Mz on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @06:12PM (#5295702)
Let me try to put that another way: I get the distinct impression that many men find it threatening to have the tables turned and struggle to remain in control of a process where they are used to initiating. I have put a lot of thought into how it works to signal receptivity selectively because it really has gone extremely poorly for me to initiate, even though I have a long track record of being heavily sought after by men. I have trouble reconciling the two sets of experiences without viewing it as mostly rooted in biased social expectations about who is allowed to do the asking.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by auggierose on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @06:31PM (#5295812)
a) Are the men who are "soughing after you" as desirable to you as the ones you are after when you take the initiative?

b) Are you more nervous when you take the initiative yourself?

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Mz on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @07:01PM (#5295976)
In most cases, I was pretty sure they were interested before I decided to bring it up. Me initiating caused back pedaling. So the groups have substantial overlap. The problem seems to very much be that I am not supposed to be proactive, etc.

I don't know how to answer that second question. I initiated with my ex husband. We were married more than two decades. But he very likely qualifies for a diagnosis of Asperger's and was often clueless when women flirted with him. More "normal" men seem to be shocked and appalled that I would take an interest in them and express it. As best I can tell, it has nothing to do with me being nervous. As best I can tell, it has to do with being perceived as a dragon lady.

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by natrius on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @05:43PM (#5295518)
It rarely works for many men, too.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Mz on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @05:46PM (#5295538)
My impression is men get told "no" a lot, not "sure, honey, I would be happy to use you like a kleenex and discard you" or "Stalker!"

But have an upvote, because you are essentially correct.

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by beachstartup on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @05:58PM (#5295604)
men have to deal with women who never call back after sex or a lesser hookup either. it happens a lot, men just don't talk about it because it's:

1. seen as unmanly to not have a women want to sleep with you again

2. seen as manly to not want to sleep with her again anyway

for the two somewhat paradoxical reasons above, men just don't talk about it in open conversation very much.

either way though, outside of serious relationships i'd say that 20% of the men are having 80% of the sex. the rest are either pretending or just don't participate in dating/hooking up. this is the cruel reality of modern dating. nobody feels sorry for guys, either, especially not women.

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by rozap on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @06:02PM (#5295638)
Not entirely true. The tactfulness of response given is really a function of how much of an asshole someone is, rather than their gender.

Both men and women get rejected in polite, and awful ways. It's just life.

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by thirdtruck on Thursday February 28, 2013 @09:15AM (#5298695)
I've entered a budding relationship with a pretty neat woman just last week because of her initiative, so I'm glad to report it can happen.

The good news: that approach filters out the men with gender-relations issues sooner rather than later, leaving more time for those few that make it through.

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Mz on Thursday February 28, 2013 @10:11AM (#5298953)
I married a man I initiated a relationship with. But we were good friends in high school and married young. I am curious how old you and your lady are and how you met, if you don't mind sharing.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by thirdtruck on Thursday February 28, 2013 @05:09PM (#5301431)
I'm 29 and she's around 33.

We've worked in the same building for a few years (different employers) but only small-talked on rare occasions until lately.

If I recall correctly, she mentioned taking in a kitten that had wandered into the lobby of our tiny building. I explained that I had let him in, and out of the cold, before that. She suggested drink and we eventually hit the bar and it escalated from there.

Moral of the story: help save every lost kitten that you find.

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Mz on Thursday February 28, 2013 @05:31PM (#5301567)
Thanks. That's helpful information.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by codex on Thursday February 28, 2013 @04:18PM (#5301091)
Men have a hunting instinct that must be engaged, and if it's not engaged, the courtship software routine just doens't run. Men need to bat their claws at a string.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Mz on Thursday February 28, 2013 @04:32PM (#5301169)
Have an upvote, if only for being giggle-worthy. I have been trying to mentally model this as "no one should be treated as an object, men don't like it anymore than I do" and looking for a path forward that allows for meaningful negotiation of terms which satisfy both parties. It's been challenging but interesting.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by codex on Friday March 01, 2013 @12:25PM (#5305580)
I think that's a laudable goal, but I think the reality is that humans are objects with human firmware. Activate the firmware routines as they were meant to be activated and you're in business. Humans have all kinds of customs modeled to the firmware, (for example, smiling and hugging and tickling) and just because you take advantage of those doesn't necessarily mean you're objectifying.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Mz on Friday March 01, 2013 @12:38PM (#5305668)
Women seem to routinely get shorted by the model we have in place currently. I am in search of a path which gives me some means to get my needs adequately met. I am clear I would rather be alone than be in a situation again which benefits a man far more than it does me and at undue expense to me. I don't think you will understand that issue, but that is the issue I am trying to sort out.
Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Shorel on Thursday February 28, 2013 @10:16AM (#5298974)
Yes, it seems men are so easy nowadays, that women have totally forgotten the ancient arts of seduction.

As far as I know, women seem to simply give up at the first obstacle. However, the numbers game is on women's favor, so it still works very well for them.

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Mz on Thursday February 28, 2013 @10:33AM (#5299080)
Funny, not promptly giving up seems to be the basis of some men viewing me as a stalker. (A reaction I also sometimes get merely for talking to a man, so, no, I don't think I am behaving pathologically.)

I am not convinced it does work well for women, but I imagine this is not the place for a meaningful discussion about that given the amount of dismissal and negativity I am being met with for commenting on my firsthand experiences. (Edit: I don't think it works well for either gender and I don't like the implied framing that this is a men against women thing. It is a situation where "winning" requires cooperation and doesn't really occur unless both a man and a woman "win.")

Re:Inventing a Dating App That Women Will Actually Use by Shorel on Thursday February 28, 2013 @06:23PM (#5301781)
Thanks, that's a good insight of the other point of view of the issue for me.