News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenJournal - Discuss academic papers (open source) by jayunit on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @04:28PM (#5288767)
Mek, this is great. Thanks for sharing & open-sourcing it. I love the idea of bringing together paper discussions online - whether post-publication peer review like f1000research.com or more casual discussion like r/science.

One challenge I've found is that it's often difficult for discussion sites to gain sufficient traction to build a critical mass of discussion - http://plasmyd.com, http://papercritic.com, http://scicombinator.com, http://chemfeeds.com.

I wonder if focusing on supporting existing small-group interactions (real-life journal clubs) would help?

I took a slightly different approach when I wrote http://www.papernautapp.com and chose instead to aggregate existing discussions about academic papers (mostly blogs, a few news sites, HN, and r/science, with a goal to cover to more sites and mailing lists). It's also freely licensed, and there are some interesting things I discovered that might be useful to OpenJournal (looking at your TODO list and GH issues):

* CrossRef.org runs a ton of cool lookup/crossref/deref services at http://labs.crossref.org/

* They also have some great libraries at https://github.com/crossref/ - who wouldn't geek out at this: http://labs.crossref.org/pdfextract/

* If you want to do some auto-identification on webpages, the https://github.com/zotero/translators project is great and actively maintained by the Zotero community.

(Some notes on how Papernaut is put together, if you're interested: http://jayunit.net/2013/01/06/papernaut-exploring-online-dis... )

Lastly, if you're fostering discussion and feedback on papers, there's overlapping interest with the http://altmetrics.org and http://altmetric.com folks.

Re:OpenJournal - Discuss academic papers (open source) by ejstronge on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @08:21PM (#5289868)
I think the issue of getting enough traction might be mitigated by restricting the papers that could be discussed. HN is a good example of this - very few posts engender discussions but those that seem promising (by the number of upvotes) are given a spotlight on the front page.

I think an improvement to the services you linked to would be to add a few new articles each week from very selective journals/conferences in each field. I imagine existing measures like a journal's impact score or the number of a conference's attendees would be a good start and tracking blogposts (as you're already doing) could be a good supplement.

This might help pull older or less visible publications out of obscurity; if something published in a domain-specific journal is germane to a discussion, a commenter might point this out while discussing a more highly visible article.

Re:OpenJournal - Discuss academic papers (open source) by mekarpeles on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @08:42PM (#5289955)
Thanks ejstronge and great idea. I'll see if I can get a group of hackers together to post one recommended paper a week.

Do you have any interest in being informed? Also, do you know anyone who may be interested in helping curate / contribute?

Re:OpenJournal - Discuss academic papers (open source) by ejstronge on Friday March 01, 2013 @12:50AM (#5303022)
Hey mekarpeles, thanks for responding. I'm a biologist by training and would be interested in joining if that's a field you'd be featuring - I think an environment where people could discuss recent, high-impact biology articles would be great.