News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Aren’t the World by asimjalis on Monday February 25, 2013 @06:37PM (#5282670)
As a thought experiment, if this was done in the US with $10k, and the other subject offered me $3000 I would take it. I would not walk away from $3000 to punish him for being unfair. If he offered me $100 I would probably walk away. So I would be more tolerant of unfairness if I was getting a large enough payout.

This is precisely how contracting shops work in the IT industry in the US. They keep the bulk of the money and pay the contractor just enough that he does not walk away from the deal.

Re:We Aren’t the World by SatvikBeri on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:26PM (#5282929)
Yeah, the relative value of the money matters a lot. To make it even more extreme, if the total was 100 million dollars and I was offered 1 million, I would take it. But if the total was $100 and I was offered $10, I'd probably refuse.

The bit about offering more than 60% in gift-giving cultures and having the other player still reject them is surprising. What would explain that?

Re:We Aren’t the World by astine on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:33PM (#5282965)
In the article they mentioned later that in gift-giving cultures receiving a gift make one indebted. They are rejecting the offers, not because they are too small, but because they are too big. The people offering as much as 60% are doing so to gain favours.
Re:We Aren’t the World by lucastx on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:02AM (#5284086)
But wasn't the offers anonymous?

Maybe it is even worse this way: you get indebted to an unknown person!

Re:We Aren’t the World by yk on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:22AM (#5284446)
Probably there is some heuristics at work, which gives the intuition that a too good split is somehow dangerous. (Similar to how people who are afraid of the dark try to avoid both caves and cellars. )
Re:We Aren’t the World by markdown on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:45PM (#5283031)
Wait, why would you ever refuse a gift?

I don't get that.

If someone offered me a dollar out of his million, I'd accept it and be very grateful.

Re:We Aren’t the World by intended on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:51AM (#5284383)
Break it down this way. Its about the way people in different cultures reflexively parse incomplete information.

The issue is that you have unspoken assumptions - Its just some guy giving you a buck, no other costs/strings or concerns to deal with. Take buck, move on.

Now lets say you are in a gift giving culture, or even better, a "high-context culture".

Whose giving you the money? A buck? From a millionaire? Are there strings attached? Nothing is free so whats going on?

So on and so forth.

Re:We Aren’t the World by j_baker on Monday February 25, 2013 @09:08PM (#5283419)
Human beings are irrational and sometimes do things that aren't in their economic best interest out of principle or ethics. Think about it: if I murder somebody, then offer you $100 not to tell anyone, would you take the money? I certainly hope not.

And yet, from a strictly economic perspective, that's a fundamentally terrible decision. Not only will you lose $100, but you'd lose tons of time you could be working talking to the police, testifying in court, etc.

Re:We Aren’t the World by jorleif on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @03:25AM (#5284584)
It seems that no one has mentioned that the effect of relative wealth might be severe also from a rationality point of view. In a more primitive environment, if your neighbor becomes too powerful, he might enslave or even kill you, so better keep him in his place.

Similarly, if you take the $100 and are silent, and protect the killer, you risk severe punishment if you are caught. Even if I agree that the decision is made based on moral conscience for most people rather than economic calculation (which might be the case for sociopaths), there is a rational basis for this. Fundamentally, to make sure that I don't get murdered myself by the murderer later, I better not comply with him, as he is proven to be ruthless. In addition, because other people are moral beings as well, $100 is a very small compensation for risking jail and being shunned for the rest of your life, a very bad economic decision.

Re:We Aren’t the World by yakiv on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:44AM (#5284191)

    > Human beings are irrational and sometimes do things that
    > aren't in their economic best interest out of principle
    > or ethics.
Humans might be irrational sometimes, but this isn't one of those times. "Rationality" has no meaning outside of the context of a goal . . . the sentence I quoted makes it seem like you're saying people should only care about their economic (do you mean financial/material?) interests.

You also said

    > Think about it: if I murder somebody, then offer you $100
    > not to tell anyone, would you take the money? I certainly
    > hope not.
so it does seem you aren't actually suggesting that.
Re:We Aren’t the World by jmduke on Monday February 25, 2013 @10:49PM (#5283829)
Talking about these things from a strictly economic perspective is always tricky, because it assumes that the economic value of things like morals and ethics are zero.
Re:We Aren’t the World by j_baker on Monday February 25, 2013 @11:42PM (#5284035)
I think the problem is that it's somewhat difficult to set a monetary value on the value of abstract concepts such as morals and ethics more than anything else.

Either way, it sounds like we agree that there's a social contract that may cause individuals to act in a manner that isn't immediately economically advantageous.

Re:We Aren’t the World by qxf2 on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @05:00AM (#5284783)
I get your point. Its summed up well in the article:

>>" “It just seemed ridiculous to the Machiguenga that you would reject an offer of free money,” says Henrich. “They just didn’t understand why anyone would sacrifice money to punish someone who had the good luck of getting to play the other role in the game.”"

I'll try and explain the counter point: Lets say you me and the researcher are playing this game. The researcher ponies up $1m and asks you to split it with me. Now, I view $1 million as the total gift. I also think you and me BOTH bring something to the table:

a) You: The decision making - which you value at $xa.

b) Me: The veto powers - which I value at some $ xb. The closer $(1m-xa) is to my xb, the more I want to do business with you. The farther apart the numbers are, I feel like you are not respecting the value I bring to the table. I don't want to do business with people that don't value my skills and respect my power.

I'm thinking that the Machiguenga and you don't really see (b) - you just see you at zero and anything above that as yay! Nothing wrong with that. I get that thinking too. Its the basis of the article - Americans are not the world.

Re:We Aren’t the World by SatvikBeri on Monday February 25, 2013 @09:37PM (#5283545)
It's dangerous to try to answer "why". I could easily rationalize an answer, but as the article shows, people's reactions are mostly cultural.

Keep in mind that the experiment is not framed as "Person A is giving you $X out of his money" but "Person A chooses the split that you and he get from the researcher's money." If it were marketed as a gift, responses to the experiment would probably be very different (including my own response.)

Re:We Aren’t the World by ShardPhoenix on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:06PM (#5283134)
You might refuse if you're pre-commiting to fairness (which could be correct in some situations and decision theories).
Re:We Aren’t the World by dspeyer on Monday February 25, 2013 @09:20PM (#5283465)
It's not his million. It's the researcher's million, which the offerer is proposing a way to split.
Re:We Aren’t the World by recoiledsnake on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:50PM (#5283060)
The game is that if you refuse, the person loses their $999,999.
Re:We Aren’t the World by markdown on Monday February 25, 2013 @09:08PM (#5283418)
Which makes it even more horrifying. Why would you cause someone to lose something because they gave you some of it?

It's pure evil.

Re:We Aren’t the World by detst on Monday February 25, 2013 @09:40PM (#5283563)
It's not their money "to lose".

Neither player has any right to the money until the game is over and the game isn't over until they've both made a decision. That's the difference between this game and a millionaire offering you money. You may be lucky to be offered anything in both cases but in one you are being screwed in the context of the game. It's a matter of returning the favor. It may not be the most economically sound decision but if the amount lost isn't significant to you, it doesn't matter.

> It's pure evil.

"markdown took $99 of $100?! He caused me to lose money. He's pure evil." No. It's not my money to lose but I don't like the way you played the game so I'll pass on the $1, thanks.

Re:We Aren’t the World by JoshTriplett on Monday February 25, 2013 @06:54PM (#5282761)
> If he offered me $100 I would probably walk away.

Why? Do you really consider it worth $100 to you just to prevent someone else from getting $9900, or do you just value $100 so little that you are willing to round it down to $0?

I can imagine real-world scenarios in which I might spend $100 worth of my time to try to address a problem, especially if I think that problem might affect others. (Scenarios involving an actual $100 seem even less likely, but plausible for a sufficiently egregious wrong.)

However, as a game, I'd call it free money no matter the amount; neither player did anything in particular to earn the money other than taking their time to play the game, and I don't see it as even slightly unfair of the first player to offer less money to the second, so I don't see any value in "punishing" the first player. The first player happened to get the better opportunity, and the second player gets to choose between having something or having nothing. In the game version, I'd place zero value on how much the first player gets.

Now, if I thought I could bluff the first player via advance communication into believing that I'd reject the offer if less than a certain amount, I'd certainly do it; however, if they called the bluff, I'll take what I can get.

Re:We Aren’t the World by luser001 on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:22PM (#5282911)
> Why? Do you really consider it worth $100 to you just to prevent someone else from getting $9900, or do you just value $100 so little that you are willing to round it down to $0?

Not the original commenter. But yes to both.

Look up multi-round games. Strategies fit for single-round games don't work in multi-round ones. Many of our strategies and heuristics are meant for multiround games, which is what most life interactions are.

By overanalyzing the experiment and treating it "just" as a experiment, imho, you are actually defeating the point of the experiment. ymmv, just my 2 cents and other disclaimers.

Re:We Aren’t the World by yesbabyyes on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:42PM (#5283304)
This is a favorite game of mine and I've given it some thought. I think an alternate formulation might give the typical HN reader new insight in the game.

Let's say I tell you I have an idea for a company. It's a really cool idea and if we realize it we will make boatloads of money. I need your help to realize it. If you agree, you will get 20% of the company. If you don't, we won't realize it and neither of us will make any money.

Do you accept? If not, why not?

Re:We Aren’t the World by DanBC on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:49PM (#5283333)
> Do you accept? If not, why not?

Almost no one on HN will agree. (I predict.) Ideas are easy. Even I have ideas. Doing something with the idea is what counts. That starts with programming, but also involves selling product and running the company. So unless the idea-person has a great record of implementing great ideas and good exits people will be unwilling to lumber themselves with a lot of work for so little return.

Re:We Aren’t the World by olivier1664 on Monday February 25, 2013 @10:28PM (#5283753)
Maybe yes. Really depends of what can be "boatloads of money" and the current appreciation of realize it. Supposing I have nothing better to do, and that you are a good team mate, I will certainly accept. This means your proposition will be more valuable to a fresh greek student without green card than to an experimented coder at Google.
Re:We Aren’t the World by sebcat on Monday February 25, 2013 @09:44PM (#5283586)
Not the same game, as there is no cost (time, money) in the original idea to compensate for. In your version you have to work to achieve a goal.
Re:We Aren’t the World by dchmiel on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:21PM (#5282905)
Both players are aware that the opportunity comes from just being lucky enough to be chosen to dictate the terms. I know you didn't earn the 10,000 so by you offering 100 dollars and you keeping 9,900 is insulting to some people and they do want to punish the 'lucky' player. It's not that they don't value the money they value punishing them to teach them a lesson at $100.

Would your answer be the same if I said I'd keep 9,999,999.99 and gave you only a penny. Would the value of punishing me be so low that now you'd consider to do so, or is it still free money and the absolute value doesn't affect you personally?

Re:We Aren’t the World by icebraining on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:28PM (#5282943)
One should also consider other implications. If the money came from nothing, I'd probably take the penny; but I'd rather let whoever funded the research keep the money than give it to such an uncharitable person.

I know this might destroy the purpose of the experiment, but frankly, they just need to take that into account.

Re:We Aren’t the World by harryh on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:23PM (#5282921)
Would you take a penny if you knew the other guy was keeping $9999.99?
Re:We Aren’t the World by astine on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:40PM (#5283007)
That's not really a fair question. Pennies aren't worth the hassle of having to carry them around. That's like asking if I'd be willing to let the other guy have the money if he offered me effectively nothing.
Re:We Aren’t the World by recoiledsnake on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:52PM (#5283070)
Where would you draw the line? 5c, 10c, 50c, $1 or $5?
Re:We Aren’t the World by Nursie on Monday February 25, 2013 @06:55PM (#5282763)
Wow, that kinda sucks. Do you mean computer-related contracting or in general?

Over here in the good-ol UK I set my rate (which the customer knows about) and my agent tries to get as much on top as they can, but AFAICT (and I have relatives who are agents) the split is usually around 80-20. Which is still a lot of cash just for fixing me up with work...

Re:We Aren’t the World by mcguire on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:18PM (#5282892)
In Texas, a few years ago, I was getting around 85%. Currently, or in other locations, I don't know. And at my current, government, contractor...I don't even want to think about it.
Re:We Aren’t the World by brightsize on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:30PM (#5282947)
Look up their GSA schedule. Find your job title. A few years back I was making a little over $100K/yr for an offence contractor and they were billing around 3x that per year for my services.
Re:We Aren’t the World by dspeyer on Monday February 25, 2013 @09:20PM (#5283466)
That effect has been studied too, and you're right about the quantity effect. At least in India.