News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by DanBC on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:26AM (#5278844)
> * In upholding the first instance decision, the Court of Appeal reiterated the principle in cases where there are competing explanations for a particular loss that causation cannot be established only by a process of elimination such that the 'least unlikely' cause of a loss is identified. A claimant must demonstrate that the particular version of events that they rely upon is more likely to have happened than not, in order for the civil burden of proof to be satisfied.*

I'm not sure what the problem is.

"It could have been A, B, or C. It's really unlikely to have been A or B, and thus it must be C" is obviously flawed, because for all we know it could have been D, and even if it was C you need to show (on the balance of probabilities) that C is the cause. Not just that C is more likely than A or B.

Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by jacques_chester on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:35AM (#5278891)
It's not the judge's role to independently nominate D. It's up to the lawyers for the plaintiff and the respondent to present facts and make legal arguments.

The judge's role is to weigh those legal arguments, and in (most) civil trials to weigh the facts presented on the balance of probability, and to render a decision.

If you require judges to run a Bayesian network over the entire universe for each case, the legal system will get a wee bit slower.

Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by Anderkent on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:40AM (#5278912)
It's not the judge's role to independently nominate D.

But that is exactly why the judge can not assume all possibilities were enumerated, and requires positive evidence for C, rather than negative evidence for A and B.

Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by jacques_chester on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:53AM (#5278954)
Judges, oddly enough, decide cases according to the rules of legal reasoning. They cannot and won't introduce their own evidence. A judge that did so would be rightly removed from the bench.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by Anderkent on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:59AM (#5278969)
So you agree then? I did not say a judge should propose any evidence.

Perhaps it's easiest to explain with an example. Let's say the defence argues for A, and prosecution argues for B. The prosecution shows that the probability of A being true is 1%. The judge can not take that as a B having a probability of 99%, since it may be that C is true.

Thus the judge requires prosecution to show that B is 50%+ likely, not that A is unlikely.

Does that make more sense?