People love to think they know some obscure wrinkle, some cool loophole, some nifty curio about the law. But so many of the stories you hear are just stories.
ps. a better way to get disqualified is to have studied law.
In the American rules of evidence, evidence is only admissible if its probative value outweighs its prejudicial effect. That's why, for example, judges ban information, generally, of past crimes. While criminals tend to be more likely to commit another crime, the jury gives such evidence weight beyond its actual value. The same can be true of expert statistical testimony.
Could you elaborate? What kind of (valid) use does DNA evidence has that is disproved by bayesian reasoning?
Cops find criminal's blood at crime scene. Cops track down murder suspect using security video. Find suspect. Take DNA sample. Sample matches DNA at crime scene. DNA proves guilt beyond reasonable doubt 1:1000000.
Example DNA not useful:
Cops find suspect's blood at crime scene. Cops peek in DNA database and find 3 people in the region with matching DNA. One of them sort of looks like the shadow in the security video. They arrest him, get him picked out of a lineup and say DNA matches blood at the crime scene in the trial. Cops say DNA evidence proves guilt with odds 1:1000000, but odds of innocence are the complete opposite and closer to, say, 1000:1.
Classic. I was told (at same uni) that, in a case involving DNA evidence, I could ask to be dismissed from a Jury, citing training in Bayesian statistics (which was prohibited because reversing the scientific certainty to look at false positives, in cases with weak circumstantial evidence, essentially kills DNA evidence's usefulness. If someone was in the right city, you expect hundreds of DNA matches out of millions of people, but if you can track them to the right street at the right time, you would expect 0.001 matches, and thus the evidence points to them much more strongly.)