News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by smoyer on Monday February 25, 2013 @07:54AM (#5278693)
What's the chance that the legal system would suddenly become coherent if we replaced all lawyers (and therefore judges) with mathematicians?
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by rayiner on Monday February 25, 2013 @10:44AM (#5279447)
90% of the work of a jury trial is managing human reactions to things. There are things that judges need to know about statistics. E.g. That in modern DNA forensics, lab error totally dominates the probability of a coincidental match, limiting accuracy to 1-2%. On the other hand, they must be deeply cognizant of human responses. A mathematician, told that some test shows a person 1,000 times more likely than average to be the killer, will intuitively realize that the person is still unlikely to be the killer. A jury of ordinary people won't. We have judges precisely to mediate between these two domains.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by jacques_chester on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:26AM (#5278850)
The law is highly coherent.

But it deals with the largest and messiest possible problem domain: everything humans do.

Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by danso on Monday February 25, 2013 @10:24AM (#5279332)
Well, "everything humans do" includes creating the law, so by that definition, the law is highly incoherent.

And a close reading of the law reveals this. In fact, it is often by close readings of the law (and precedent and every other historical quirk) on which controversial and contested decisions are rendered

Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by jacques_chester on Monday February 25, 2013 @06:54PM (#5282756)
> Well, "everything humans do" includes creating the law, so by that definition, the law is highly incoherent.

Which meaning of incoherent are we taking here?

> And a close reading of the law reveals this.

Do go on.

Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by mich41 on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:24AM (#5278837)
Mathematicians are people who define probability as the measure of some well-defined subset of some well-defined set of all events.

The people who use probability theory to build approximate models of real world events are called statisticians (and those who forget about "approximate" - applied statisticians).

Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by Mvandenbergh on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:13AM (#5278784)
Zero.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by muuh-gnu on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:04AM (#5278739)
Lwayers are not the problem. The law makers and the law making and decision making process is the problem.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by jacques_chester on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:58AM (#5278966)
In common law countries there are three main tributaries of law: legislation, the common law, and equity. Depending on where you are, the latter two are sometimes "fused" into a single type of law.

"Law makers" -- I presume you mean legislators -- only control legislation. This is often called "positive law", in that somebody has to take positive action to "make" it where it didn't exist before.

By convention, the common law is considered to be "discovered". It exists independent of men and women, and the role of judges is to determine what it is.

In practice there is a dynamic tension between the evolution of the common law as it finds and adapts to new problems, and the intervention of the legislature when it decides that the law should be something else. Legislation itself quickly accretes case law that decides what the given piece of legislation means.

Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by jheriko on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:17AM (#5278804)
it might become consistent but at the cost of being complete... or the other way around. ;)
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by jheriko on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:18AM (#5278805)
er... not being complete XD