Re:Ask HN: Review my relaunched startup
by typicaljoe on Sunday March 22, 2009 @02:38PM
(#527311)
What browser are you using that the editor stopped working? You can do any subject you want, in fact I may even add it to the list. I added the box on the left to give the site some initial focus.
I tried both FF3 and Safari3 on Mac.
Ah, I see -- I misunderstood the "let me know". I got the impression that new subjects had to go through you.
My other comments stand, though. You need an info/UI designer to go over the site, and you need to improve the value prop to contributors. There are lots of sites in similar areas -- three that come to mind are squidoo, mahalo, and twine.
The design is a turn-off.
The demo editor does not work. I gave my page a name, but none of the link or text buttons work.
Posting a review request at noon on Sunday limits your exposure.
I don't quite get the value prop here -- even if making a page is "easy", it's not easier than writing something on my own blog.
I can't open my own subjects without asking you? What if I don't care about the dozen languages listed?
Server went down at this point. Sorry, man. This is a nice idea but you'll need to give users more power and more reason to use it. Maybe importing links from delicious or similar.