News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by zxcdw on Saturday February 23, 2013 @03:28PM (#5271336)
When will we be in a world when we don't have to deal with assembly language at all? When can we just get the job done without having to understand or know any of the things which go down there? Because that stuff pisses me off. Bits? Bytes? I just want that freaking login box and implement some functionality and never have to deal what's under. Is it really that hard? Sigh.
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by jacquesm on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:03PM (#5271498)
When will we be in a world when we don't have to deal with molecules at all? When we can just get the job done without having to understand or know any of the things which go down there? Because that stuff pisses me off. Protons? Electrons? I just want that freaking light to come on and implement some functionality and never have to deal [with] what's under[neath]. Is it really that hard? Sigh.

--

I don't particularly like that style of arguing a point but this is just asking for it. Knowing a higher level of abstraction without knowing a lower level of abstraction is just fine. But knowing a lower level of abstraction will give you a definite edge and if there is one thing that hackers are always looking for then it is a way to have an edge over the rest. A way to do something that is deemed impossible simply by knowing a bit more, a way to achieve some feat by exploiting knowledge that is maybe a bit harder to come by but not impossible. The ultimate level playing field, you get as many tools as you're willing to learn how to use, with only your attitude towards learning and your perseverance as the limiting factors.

Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by joezydeco on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:09PM (#5271532)
I was going to write a similar analogy, but not as abstract as that. I was thinking more like the automotive industry.

Most people want to just be able to buy and drive it off the lot without having to understand how it works or what makes it tick inside. But there will always be a need for automotive engineers.

Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by greenyoda on Saturday February 23, 2013 @05:39PM (#5271797)
Also, knowing a bit about how your car works will make you less likely to get ripped off by a dishonest or incompetent mechanic.
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by tjoff on Sunday February 24, 2013 @02:47AM (#5273324)
Also it will make you drive better and more efficient as well as care for it, resulting in a far less need of an mechanic in the first place.
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by jasonjei on Saturday February 23, 2013 @03:39PM (#5271386)
The answer is probably never. There will be deeper levels of abstraction, and the OS, for the most part, will do a marvelous job hiding it, but without a strong understanding of assembly you'll never be able to work on things like memory management, efficiency algorithms, and so forth. For example, assembly forces you to think in terms of bits, so knowing word-aligned vs non word-aligned code can make drastic differences in speed. Also, knowing how 64-bit is different from 32-bit makes a world of difference. Assembly forces you to think in those contexts.

For the most part, the average programmer today already does not need to know assembly. But if you want to work on other low-level aspects of code (or optimize your code for efficiency), knowledge of assembly is critical. You might not have to write very much assembly, but things like context-switching that happens on the CPU level (e.g kernel land vs user land) can only be done by sending the right instructions to the CPU.

Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by tjoff on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:00PM (#5271477)
You don't have to deal with what's down under. Your loss really. So I don't understand what's bothering you.

On the other hand, those that do understand what's going on down under have to endure with the high-level crap of unimaginable proportions every day.

If "programming" is so easy that you don't really have to know anything to do it the result is going to suck. Case in point: Android and iOS.

The world would be a better place everyone were required to know assembly before doing an web app.

Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by TallGuyShort on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:36PM (#5271624)
Someone will always have to understand every part of the stack. If that person's not you, then just move on. I don't give a crap about browser UI and I wish I lived in a world where we didn't have to deal with that. But in reality, I'm glad somebody cares about it, and if someone writes an article about that world - more power to them.
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by _delirium on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:02PM (#5271490)
A large portion of professional software development doesn't ever touch asm, so the answer can be "today" if you want.
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by regularfry on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:30PM (#5271607)
My day-to-day job is web dev. But yesterday, I dug up references I haven't read in years and wrote a bootloader. Why? Because it turns out that for some things, speed and simplicity really matter.

Also, I haven't had this much fun doing development in ages.

Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by Lerc on Saturday February 23, 2013 @05:18PM (#5271733)
So here's the tricky question...

Why was it fun?

Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by regularfry on Monday February 25, 2013 @04:19AM (#5278022)
Good question. I think it's something to do with the impression that if something doesn't work, I can have absolute confidence that it's something that I've done wrong. There's no question of "bugs in the framework"[0]. There's also the matter that this is one area where code golf is actually practical, and can make the difference between being able to do something and simply not.

[0] Yes, I know there are hardware bugs. In the sort of thing I'm doing? Not hugely relevant.

Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by windexh8er on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:31PM (#5271611)
So ignorance is bliss? I guess there will always be a fundamental requirement to know the root of all operations. But, good luck in hoping otherwise.
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by iamrohitbanga on Saturday February 23, 2013 @03:43PM (#5271405)
When we actually get to use qubits may be?
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by rdouble on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:01PM (#5271487)
Can't tell if serious...
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by zxcdw on Saturday February 23, 2013 @06:14PM (#5271900)
No. :) I tried to parodize a bit but I guess it wasn't very succesful.
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by scotth on Saturday February 23, 2013 @03:42PM (#5271402)
Not sure why you're being downvoted. It's an opinion, people.
Re:Why Learning Assembly Language Is Still a Good Idea (2004) by lttlrck on Saturday February 23, 2013 @06:58PM (#5272011)
we?

If it's not your bag my friend, walk on.