Re:FPGA x86 Processor
by edwintorok on Saturday February 23, 2013 @05:03PM
(#5271697)
It looks like he only wants to emulate 8086, so ACPI and booting Windows/Linux are not a possibility.
Not saying that its simple to implement an 8086, but it should be significantly easier than implementing an 80386/80486 (which is what one would expect today as a minimum when referring to it as x86).
Re:FPGA x86 Processor
by raverbashing on Sunday February 24, 2013 @02:55AM
(#5273341)
Aah that changes the picture
Maybe he can boot FreeDOS then (not sure if it uses i386 mode, probably not)
It would be nice to boot, to show something, maybe even play an old game
OS bringup doesn't seem to be part of the goal. It looks like he's just going to run code directly from memory to test it without worrying about needing to get an OS running on it first.
Re:FPGA x86 Processor
by PedroDiogo_ on Saturday February 23, 2013 @03:26PM
(#5271322)
I'm not sure it that's the focus of the project.
If this is his final EE project as said on the page, in my opinion the main focus of the project is to have a working proof of concept of an implementation of a X86 processor on a FPGA.
He wouldn't have the time to build a fully ready to market X86 processor all by himself, I think.
Just reuse SeaBIOS like QEMU and KVM do! http://www.seabios.org/SeaBIOS
Why?
Having tested an x86 processor from a 3rd party manufacturer (not the big ones, and not even the 2nd league)
- Bios. Including ACPI stuff. So Windows XP would boot, with linux some would boot, some would work but with instabilities, some would not boot
- Minor incompatibilities and every nook and cranny of the x86 spec.
- Drivers for everything your board does different
- The x86 (legacy) infrastructure. Not sure how much you need to boot and make Windows work for example. It may get nasty. A20? Chained interrupt handlers? DMA controllers?