Re:Bitter Pill: Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us
by rdl on Friday February 22, 2013 @10:09PM
(#5268375)
There should be a way to pay cash (if you prepay) and get the lowest price available (legally, the medicare rate; I think the government legally requires the hospital to give it the best rate offered to anyone.)
The one big advantage of my $3500 annual deductible HSA (+RX) for everything routine is that I get Blue Shield's negotiated rates even though I effectively pay out of pocket for my <$500 in annual medical expenses. Out of pocket without insurance, I'd probably be paying $1-2k. Then, on top of that, I get the unlimited lifetime catastrophic 100% coverage after $3500 or $6000 or whatever, so if I had a serious medical issue in any given year, my total costs would be $1500 or so for annual premium plus the $6k out of pocket maximum.
If you're healthy, the HSA seems like the ideal plan, and really is how all insurance should be run. The weak link is that doctors/hospitals don't disclose prices upfront, and really have no way to telling you how much something will cost under your insurance, so it's hard to price shop.
The one big advantage of my $3500 annual deductible HSA (+RX) for everything routine is that I get Blue Shield's negotiated rates even though I effectively pay out of pocket for my <$500 in annual medical expenses. Out of pocket without insurance, I'd probably be paying $1-2k. Then, on top of that, I get the unlimited lifetime catastrophic 100% coverage after $3500 or $6000 or whatever, so if I had a serious medical issue in any given year, my total costs would be $1500 or so for annual premium plus the $6k out of pocket maximum.
If you're healthy, the HSA seems like the ideal plan, and really is how all insurance should be run. The weak link is that doctors/hospitals don't disclose prices upfront, and really have no way to telling you how much something will cost under your insurance, so it's hard to price shop.