Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by kanzure on Friday February 22, 2013 @03:03PM
(#5266421)
This is a fantastic development. What are the chances of any of this applying retroactively to papers that are already published?
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by michael_nielsen on Friday February 22, 2013 @03:05PM
(#5266429)
In the case of FASTR, I don't think there's anything in there about it being retroactive. Certainly there's not for the existing NIH policy. In the case of the Whitehouse Directive, I suppose individual agencies could decide to adopt a retroactive policy. But I don't think such a policy is being prescribed.
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by kanzure on Friday February 22, 2013 @03:08PM
(#5266447)
Thank you. The reason I ask is because many of the articles that I am currently reading or need to read are those that were published prior to the existence of FASTR, in particular recent papers published between, say, the 1920s and 2010s. In due time, these articles that are locked away will be less referenced, but in the mean time I am left scratching my head... will we just try to forget that this terrible plague ever happened to science, and re-publish as much as possible?
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by bendmorris on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:59PM
(#5268180)
>I suppose individual agencies could decide to adopt a retroactive policy.
I don't think they could. If they've already signed a contract to fund a project, they can't just decide to change the rules. This will only count going forward.
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by michaelhoffman on Friday February 22, 2013 @04:34PM
(#5267006)
The chances are zero. There is no way for the government to retroactively change the terms and conditions of contracts and grants that were executed long ago.
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by Alex3917 on Friday February 22, 2013 @04:45PM
(#5267070)
That's not accurate, they could grant themselves a license to the copyright under eminent domain.
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by betterunix on Friday February 22, 2013 @04:57PM
(#5267148)
Or just retroactively reduce the lengths of copyright terms. After all, they retroactively increase the lengths of those terms all the time, so why can they not reduce them as well? The constitution explicitly requires copyrights to expire, but makes no specific mention of what the minimum or maximum terms are.
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by temphn on Saturday February 23, 2013 @01:08AM
(#5268749)
California just enacted a massive retroactive tax. If they want to, they will do what they want.
http://www.xconomy.com/san-francisco/2013/01/15/california-t...
http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2013/02/21/the-california-tax-th...
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday February 23, 2013 @05:34AM
(#5269263)
Then some billionaires need to buy Elvesier et al and do so. That for my money, would be one of the best things to happen to science as the result of profit.
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by yukoncornelius on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:36PM
(#5267350)
I'm not sure if this is a fantastic development. Placing a copy of the journal article on the agency website is cheap, but the burden of opening the data is going to be costly. This may cut funds available for subsequent research due to reallocation of the funds to opening the research to the public.
Re:Increasing Public Access to the Results of Scientific Res...
by jacquesm on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:22PM
(#5267287)
The gray area here is 1996 up to the present. Anything before that has not been licensed to publishers if that was not explicitly arranged.
After 1996 you could presumably take it as read that digital rights were included when you transferred copyrights.
This suggestion is similar to the NIH public access policy (adopted in 2008), which requires the results of NIH-funded research to be made freely available within 12 months of publication. The new memorandum gives agencies some freedom in how they respond - they don't need to adopt exactly the NIH policy - but it is clearly in the same spirit.
Here's an analysis from Peter Suber, a leading advocate of open access: https://plus.google.com/109377556796183035206/posts/8hzviMJe...
Suber focuses on the connection to FASTR, a major piece of open access legislation introduced into Congress a few days ago. Broadly, FASTR has a lot of overlap with the White House directive. FASTR would require every Federal agency with a budget over 100 million to adopt an open access policy. A significant difference - and one that I expect is of interest to HN - is that FASTR has provisions to enable text mining. That would potentially be of interest to some startups. Much more info here:
http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/hoap/Notes_on_the_Fair_Access_t...
If you'd like to support open access, take a few minutes to look at the Alliance for Taxpayer Access's (ATA) call to action on FASTR:
http://www.taxpayeraccess.org/action/FASTR_calltoaction.shtm...
It is also of interest to follow the responses from John Wilbanks and Heather Joseph, two of the authors of the petition (and long-time advocates for open access):
https://twitter.com/wilbanks
https://twitter.com/hjoseph
Wilbanks notes that the memo covers research from "NSF, Ed, EPA, NASA, USDA, HHS, Commerce, Interior, Defense, Energy, Trans, DHS, Ag, State, Smithsonian". He also implies that while this memo is great progress, it falls short of a full open access mandate enabling reuse and text-mining of content.