Re:Goodbye Google: "Visual Design Lead" leaves Google
by gnaritas on Saturday March 21, 2009 @03:59PM
(#526513)
You're moving the goal post. No one's talking about desktop apps, you said web apps. Web apps are a different space and sound is just not appropriate there, and it likely won't ever be.
Re:Goodbye Google: "Visual Design Lead" leaves Google
by pxlpshr on Saturday March 21, 2009 @05:15PM
(#526620)
There are many cases that justify when to use and when not use sound on the web...
I would say it's the goal of most web-app builders to mimic desktop apps b/c the result is a familiar environment for the end user. Software/UI design is an established practice, with many studied and proven methodologies for handling complex user interaction that has been unfamiliar to the web in former years.
That said, I believe it's inevitable that web-apps will mirror their desktop counter-parts in time (many are doing so already)... the exception being, highly-specialized web apps.
Agree or Disagree: Twitter clients are an example of sound feedback hooking users attention (among other things), where the web was failing to do so.
Success of Google and 'design sensibilities' is not really an argument worth correlating; there are companies like Apple that master both engineering and design... tremendously successful. Furthermore, one could argue that Google Calendar is a near exact rip off of iCal, no credit to Google except putting it on the cloud and syncing it with their own software suite. I think influence is great, but goog engineers are not necessarily to credit for design and usability in this and other products.