News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:06PM (#5254346)
It doesn't matter if they are Microsoft II since Microsoft is their only competition in this space.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by vecter on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:25PM (#5254450)
I don't know why you're saying that, disruption is right around the corner:

http://greenthrottle.com/ - Play mobile games on your TV

http://www.bluestacks.com/ - Play mobile games on your PC

http://www.ouya.tv/ - Android gaming console

http://www.theverge.com/2013/2/6/3958162/valve-steam-box-cak... - Play games sold on Steam directly on your TV

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by phaus on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:47PM (#5254569)
With the exception of the steam box, you listed mobile gaming platforms.

Mobile games thus far can be placed into one of two categories:

A: Ports of obsolete PC/Console games with terrible control schemes.

B: Casual games.

The last time around, Sony tried to position itself as the platform for hardcore gamers. It appears that they are doing the same thing with the PS4. Hardcore gamers only play casual games either when they are away from home, or when they don't have time to play on their platform of choice. I'm not sure who technically won between Sony and MS, but it wasn't a landslide victory.

Don't get me wrong, casual games are great. Nintendo, Apple and Google have proven that there is a huge market for casual games, and it probably has a larger market than there is for hardcore gaming, I don't really know. Even if it is, that doesn't necessarily mean that traditional gaming is going to die.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by skue on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:44PM (#5254820)
It's surprising to see so many people on HN of all places arguing that Sony is not competing with mobile. The previous poster used the term "disruption" for a reason - this is straight out of Innovator's Dilemma.

Sony and its advocates will argue that their focus is on serious/hardcore gamers, not casual/mobile gaming. Casual gamers don't pay premium prices and there may even be a smaller margin on mobile sales, such that it currently makes business sense to yield that market. But the PS is locked into long hardware development cycles and the platform needs to support games for years into the future, while mobile hardware is updated continuously such that the difference between the platforms will shrink - stealing away increasing numbers of consumers and development shops.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by phaus on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:09PM (#5255121)
I think that we'll eventually reach the threshold where devices of all sizes have true "retina" quality screens, along with GPUs powerful enough to back them up, but that won't happen in the next generation of consoles, and even if it did, there is still one astronomical hurdle we have to jump in order to level the playing field.

Even at it's best, controlling a 3d game with a touch screen is a horrifyingly awful experience. It's so bad that I haven't made it out of the first level of any of the games I've tried. Not because I can't clear the content, but instead because doing so is such an awkward experience, that I'd rather go back to playing angry birds or read HN. As someone who spent his teen years playing GoldenEye, TF Classic, Q3A and Counter-Strike for 12-16 hours at a time, I find it quite an accomplishment when someone manages to make a FPS that I can't stand to play for more than 5 minutes.

I think that it's possible that we'll eventually have a level playing field on all platforms, but I don't think capacitive touch screens are going to be the innovation that makes it a reality.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:26PM (#5254991)
I agree with everything you said, just not that it will happen within the timespan of this console generation.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by drewcrawford on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:19PM (#5255151)
I don't understand what you are saying. According to Apple's 2012 10K filing, both the iPhone and iPad lines independently, each year, net more than Sony's entire market cap.

How can there be any question of mobile game hardware surpassing hardcore gaming in profitability in the next console generation when it has already occurred?

If you're Activision or Blizzard, sure, the money is still in selling $60 titles. But in terms of hardware manufacturers like Sony and Microsoft, the ship has sailed.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:49PM (#5255254)
It hasn't sailed. People are still buying those games; in fact those games are still breaking sales records. Casual games may become more popular, I don't know, but it's not zero-sum when the gaming market is growing overall.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by drewcrawford on Thursday February 21, 2013 @05:49AM (#5256712)
> the gaming market is growing overall.

False: http://business.time.com/2013/02/11/game-over-why-video-game...

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by chc on Thursday February 21, 2013 @02:51AM (#5256085)
You're comparing an insanely popular mobile phone and a general-purpose computing platform to an Xbox. While they are both mobile devices and both can play games, neither is really mobile gaming hardware per se. I mean, you're obviously not wrong that making the iPhone is good business, but iPhone owners are not primarily gamers -- not even casual ones -- so counting every iPhone sold as a "game hardware" sale at this point is pretty misleading.

Most importantly to the point at hand, there is no evidence that iPhone is stealing many sales from Xbox and PS3, nor that it will start in the foreseeable future. I very, very much doubt that many people find themselves wondering whether to get an iPhone or an Xbox to play games on.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by city41 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:55PM (#5254606)
The Ouya is a console with a controller. It won't just be casual games and it won't suffer from terrible control schemes. I have my doubts it will do much to Sony, but I'm glad to see the additional options coming.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by phaus on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:15PM (#5254696)
Options are always great, and a console like Ouya will serve a lot of people better than a more expensive console.

But take a game like space invaders. When it came out, it was new and shiny and amazing. When I played it in the late 80's (My parents were too cheap for a Nintendo, I didn't play one of those until the SNES / Genesis were already out.) It was so awesome that I couldn't imagine any game ever being better. Now, decades later, it's still a good game, but it's so simplistic in comparison to current games, that I can't see myself playing it for hours on end.

Now take a game like Grand Theft Auto 3, represents one of the more complex / graphically intensive games ported to Android / IOS. When it was first released, it too was an amazing game. I spent countless hours driving around, shooting things, and completing the missions. While it was amazing for it's time, in comparison to this generation's games, the graphics are dated and the game play seems to lack depth. Once again, I can't see myself enjoying it now for more than a few minutes.

There are some games that are truly timeless, like Contra, Mario, Chess, Go, Quake 3 Arena, Mario Kart, etc.., but most console and PC games don't age well.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by msg on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:28PM (#5255003)
You had me until Contra. I loved Contra when I was that age too, but it's not in the same galaxy as Tetris, Metroid, or the original Zelda.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by phaus on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:55PM (#5255077)
I actually couldn't really get into Metroid. I'm a 3rd generation military brat that ended up joining the Army so I think the theme of Contra appealed more to me. In the grand scheme of things, I agree Metroid was more influential, but I just didn't like it.

I can't believe I forgot to mention Tetris though.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by ekianjo on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:04PM (#5254647)
Ouya is not even out yet, and just because it found 100 000 clients on Kickstarter does not mean it will be much bigger once it reaches the market. And it's probably "too cheap" in terms of hardware to motivate anyone serious with gaming to buy it.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by ekianjo on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:16PM (#5254953)
mrbill, not sure if you know but you are [dead]. Anyway, for me being serious about gaming is not just about playing good games of all ages, but also keep trying NEW games. I would not be satisfied playing with the Atari 2600 forever.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by vidarh on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:10PM (#5254676)
The Ouya is too slow to make a dent in the hardcore gamer market.

It might very well sell ok, but not to replace PS4's or any other "real" consoles.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by bennyg on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:46PM (#5255051)
I mean, spec-wise, the Ouya doesn't compare with the PS4 - 2gb ram to 8gb right off the bat.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by dmbass on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @11:42PM (#5255428)
Guess how much RAM the PS3 and 360 have.

PS3: 256MB for the Cell and GPU each 360: 512MB shared

I don't think Ouya is worth anything, but comparing RAM sizes is almost useless.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by chc on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:37PM (#5254509)
I don't know why you're saying that. These systems are completely unproven in a way that traditional consoles are not. This seems like looking at those little joystick consoles they sell at the mall that play '70s arcade games and declaring them "disruption."
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by ekianjo on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:02PM (#5254640)
You forgot "PC Gaming" which is not only Steam. It's always been there in the corner and has never disappeared because of consoles. In fact the best looking games are always on PC, and they usually target the most demanding players, while consoles are clearly mainstream.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by tacticus on Thursday February 21, 2013 @02:15AM (#5255972)
and it is still a huge part of the market.

bf3 sold more copies on PC than both "hardcore" consoles combined. http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2013/02/18/mouse-keyboard-st...?

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by jdsemrau on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:46PM (#5254565)
Wake me up when Madden and Fifa run on these.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by 404error on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:04PM (#5254648)
I'm with you on this one. I own a PS3 and for the past 3 years I've only purchased 3 games. FIFA 11, 12, and 13.

I will probably buy a PS4 just for FIFA XX

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by ekianjo on Thursday February 21, 2013 @12:26AM (#5255602)
You know you can buy the exact same games on PC cheaper, and play with a pad on it with much better resolution and Framerate?

Purchasing a console to play only non-exclusive titles... I have never understood that.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by Drakim on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:08AM (#5256132)
A gaming PC that can run these games on a better resolution and framerate costs a lot more than a PS3
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by ekianjo on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:09AM (#5256347)
Let's not start price comparisons. Can you do photoshop on PS3? Can you edit documents ? Can you run professional applications ?

A PC will ALWAYS do more things than a console, and the better you PC config is, the better all your applications will run so it's win-win for all you do with it.

Besides, even games are cheaper and faster to buy on PC. So compare the price of a PS3 with 30 games with one of a PC with 30 games and you will see your argument is wrong.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by Drakim on Thursday February 21, 2013 @07:15AM (#5256952)
The question was basically, why would anybody buy a PS3 for these games instead of a PC?

I just told you. It's cheaper. That's not some obscure "gotcha" reason.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by 404error on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:02PM (#5259895)
I could, but I've been playing with the same group of people (in a Pro Club) for the past 4 years, I'm in too deep. Plus, I just like the Playstation.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by untog on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:01PM (#5254633)
And Call of Duty. And Modern Warfare. And, and and..
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by rictic on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:11PM (#5254379)
This is a very short-sighted analysis. There are other players and forces involved in gaming than just the big three of last generation. In fact, if I had to bet, I would bet against any of them being the largest force in consumer gaming in four years.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:19PM (#5254416)
I only know what I know, and I don't know (or have heard any real rumors, for that matter) of anyone else entering the AAA-title console market. Of course secrets exist.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by Steko on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:40PM (#5254524)
The problem is the "AAA-title console market" is a subset of the "home video game market" which is of course being invaded from both ends.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:22PM (#5254977)
It's not really a problem, though. People have mistaken what is a growing market for one that is being invaded. It's just growing. Some people want casual games, which is fine, but Call of Duty games continue to break sales records, studios get bigger budgets (See Bungie's upcoming games), and those games won't play on an Ouya or an Apple TV.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by Steko on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:29PM (#5255187)
Apple's presumed console competitor hasn't even been released so it's premature to say what games won't play on it. They already pay game developers more than Microsoft and Sony combined.

My argument is not that people don't want to play CoD. My argument is that even Activision wants Apple and come in and kill the current console paradigm. They don't want to keep making 30% of $60 games that sell 10 million copies when they could be making 70% of a $10 game that moves 50 million copies.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by nemothekid on Thursday February 21, 2013 @02:48AM (#5256075)
> They don't want to keep making 30% of $60 games that sell 10 million copies when they could be making 70% of a $10 game that moves 50 million copies.

I don't understand. Are you saying that Activision should kill CoD and fund the next Angry Birds so they could sell more copies of a cheaper game, or are you saying that CoD could sell 50 million copies if it was priced at $10?

Both of those claims are questionable. I am pretty sure Activision is scared shitless of becoming the next Rovio, and I doubt CoD would even break even being priced at $10.

Considering that CoD had a 200 million dollar budget, they would need to sell 20 million copies to break even vs 3.33 million, and consider to date (4 months) they have sold 20 million copies.

Even if such a price cut caused sales to double, you would have:

20 million * $60 * 30% - $200 million = $160 million dollars

40 million * $10 * 70% - $200 million = $80 million dollars.

Again, they would break even with their old model if they sold ~50 million copies, however, I don't think "hardcore" gaming is that price sensitive, and I doubt we would see a 150% increase in sales if you cut CoD's price to $10.

Lastly, where would these people come from? I don't think Activision has an untapped market 5x their current market size that want to buy Call of Duty but only for $10. Even if you talk about opening to the "casual" market, Nintendo showed us just how toxic that is. Casual gamers don't buy games. I'm sure its a lot smarter to sell to the gamer who buy 3 games a year @ $60, than it so to sell to 5 people who will buy 1 game /year @ $10. So if Activision could sell 50 million copies of CoD, would that stick them in the same position as Rovio, where all they can do is sell CoD, while WoW and Diablo bleed cash?

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by Steko on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:29AM (#5256422)
"Even if such a price cut caused sales to double"

Wait, you're doubting whether a price cut of 85% would even double sales? With a demand curve like that someone will need to tell the game companies they are leaving billions on the table when they could be charging $150 a copy.

I'm pretty sure we'd see sales explode on price alone but the limited console installed base is also depressing game sales. A large percentage of high end console users use them primarily for netflix and other non-gaming uses but they aren't marketed effectively for these uses. Apple isn't even marketing the ipad as a game machine but they move far more $300+ units than Sony and MS put together each month.

"I don't think 'hardcore' gaming is that price sensitive"

You're talking yourself into a conclusion here. Not only "hardcore" gamers enjoy playing Call of Duty. {And the notion of console fps players being hardcore itself is problematic}

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:45PM (#5255239)
Sure, maybe Apple is going to release a high-end gaming console. And maybe they are going to release a watch. And maybe they are going to release a TV. I don't have any inside information on these things, and a gaming console hasn't (to my knowledge) even been rumored at this point. I don't know if they want to make one. I don't know if it would be profitable enough for them. I... don't know. So I'm going to just go off of what I do know, which is the XBox 720, the PS4, a huge drop off, the Wii U, a huge dropoff and various ARM based consoles.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by phaus on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:50PM (#5254579)
I guess Valve isn't a AAA publisher.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by chii on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:50AM (#5256247)
the last aaa game they published was portal 2. quite a while ago.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by cyanbane on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @11:22PM (#5255347)
I agree with this sentiment. The biggest gaming platform in 2018 is one that hasn't even been started on yet.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by wlesieutre on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:33PM (#5254490)
With console cycles getting longer and longer, the PS4 needs to be competitive for a decade. Even if Ouya and their ilk don't take off in the near future, tablets and phones will keep chipping away at console gaming.

Microsoft may be the competition right now, but they can't count on it staying that way. When the PSP and PS3 came out, the iPhone didn't exist yet, but things change.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by Volpe on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:54PM (#5254860)
The PS Vita is the answer in the mobile space, and it's release cycle will likely be shorter than the PlayStation Consoles.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by SandB0x on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:19PM (#5254417)
Until the Steam Box is out.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by klodolph on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:34PM (#5254495)
The Steam box is competition whether or not it's out, since it's on the horizon and people will potentially not buy a PS4 so they can wait and see what the Steam box is like.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by untog on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:03PM (#5254642)
Who are these people, if not PC gamers?

Steam is fantastic, but it's a name that is totally unknown to almost all console gamers. Just the presence of a Steam Box isn't going to magically convert people, they have a huge uphill struggle ahead of them. Most of their market, IMO, is PC gamers.

Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by mcantelon on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:31PM (#5255013)
Steam has a large, loyal following and, because of this, people like myself (console gamer) and my girlfriend (not a gamer) know about it through online media. I currently play PS3 games because there is no PC gaming solution I can plop down in my living room and have it just work. But once the Steam Box comes out that will change. Not only will I have a living room compatible ready-to-wear PC gaming solution, but gaming will also be cheaper because Steam has tons of deals. Steam is also reputedly a lot more developer friendly than Sony and Microsoft so I really don't see how Sony and Microsoft are going to be able to compete in the long term.
Re:Sony announces PS4 with 8-core x86 processor, 8GB GDDR5 m... by LinXitoW on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:06AM (#5256326)
By your logic, I, as purely a PC gamer, shouldn't know anything about the PS3 or the XBOX360 even existing, yet i definitely know of them.