News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by Xcelerate on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @06:58PM (#5254295)
I am surprised that so many people are relating PhD's to the money you'll make. I hear (very frequently) that "the amount of time you spend doing your PhD will put you far behind the 4 years of having a job" or "if you want to get rich, go into ...", or "management is where all the money is; you need an MBA for that".

Uh... I'm doing a PhD because I like scientific research and can't stand the thought of being a process engineer. If I'm going to spend 8 hours a day working on something for the rest of my life, it better be something I enjoy! While it is possible to do R&D with a bachelor's degree, your chances of being able to do exactly the kind of research you want goes up significantly with a PhD, plus you've already had the experience of doing it for 4 years.

Also, I'm not sure where this "not much money" concept comes from anyway. I'll start at an engineering salary, right out of grad school. I guess that's not "Hacker News wealthy", but that's plenty more than I need to even live comfortably!

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by lutorm on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:18PM (#5254412)
As long as you don't do a Ph.D. with the assumption that you will get a permanent academic job, i.e., faculty at a university.

I don't really think it's the salary of a permanent academic job that people complain about, it's the fact that in most fields, the number of such jobs is far surpassed by the number of Ph.D.'s produced. When you realize that "not that much money" means "postdoc kind of not-that-much-money", then the outlook changes.

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by yukoncornelius on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:37PM (#5255206)
Do like writing grant proposals? Because in the biological sciences that is what you will be doing, and you will be competing against other smart folks which results in a 6% chance of a successful proposal. Then you can do some research while drafting journal articles, teaching undergraduates, and working for tenure by serving on a bunch of committees.

In short, there is very little research in the above Ph.D. in academia career.

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by javert on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:11PM (#5254380)
your chances of being able to do exactly the kind of research you want goes up significantly with a PhD, plus you've already had the experience of doing it for 4 years.

I'm not so sure that's a valid generalization.

I'm getting a PhD in computer science, but any corporate R&D department I know of that would hire a fresh graduate would only let you do R in service of their particular D needs, i.e., you have too little autonomy.

I definitely think I can find jobs that I love and that are lucrative (I have some in mind), but I won't be doing research as, say, a tenured professor would define it.

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by bathat on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:34AM (#5255855)
Sure, but, unless you're a rockstar graduate student, you do R in service of your advisor's grant needs. Unless you're a rockstar post-doc, you do R in service of your PI's grant needs. Unless you're a rockstar PI, you do R in service of your own grant needs. Wherever you end up, someone is writing the checks. That someone gets to determine what you research.

I'd guess that computer science is very different from experimental physical science disciplines: In experimental, you have to have a research advisor with grant money if you want to have vacuum pumps/oscilloscopes/glassware/liquid nitrogen/etc., even if you plan to TA your way through grad school.

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by madpickle on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:57PM (#5254617)
I see this negative claim on HN quite a bit. R&D CS labs where D is in service of R do exist. I work at such a lab. We expect fresh PhDs to lead their own research project. Spend some time perusing the ACM DL in your area and try to find labs that have high publication-to-researcher ratios (many of these labs are quite small so it does no good just to do a raw pub count).
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by aheilbut on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:37PM (#5254505)
I'm not even sure that all tenured professors are doing research as they would define it.
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by lutorm on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:01PM (#5254631)
Absolutely not. Look at the publication record of any tenured professor at a non R1 university and you'll typically find that it's dropped to almost nil.
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by javert on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:05PM (#5254654)
True, I really just meant "at R1 universities." Which isn't fair to all those other tenured professors at non-R1 universities (and I may possibly even be one, someday).

Of course, I have heard of R1 tenured professors who claim to spend 50% of their effort procuring funding (though I think 10% is a much more representative estimate).

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by PeterisP on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:20PM (#5254720)
I've heard believable claims that "here professors don't write research papers, professors write grant proposals" - quite a few of them advance research and get paper authorship by leading a lab and procuring funding for the team that does the actual research and writes the papers.

And I'm not dissing them in any way - getting a grant requires the senior/experienced guys working on it. Getting the funding is a must-have (since without it researchers and students would be dismissed and the research would not exist); but spending your own time researching is a nice-to-have thing that you can do if there's any spare time left after teaching and bureaucracy.

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by aheilbut on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:26PM (#5254738)
Also, the research that people are writing grants for and doing is dictated by what is fundable, which is not necessarily exactly what they'd choose to be doing were there no constraints.
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by javert on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:09PM (#5255120)
I know tenured professors who don't apply for grants, and therefore don't have any money to pay students, but they still get paid a salary by the department. They can do whatever they want (research, or not), modulo teaching responsibilities. Some profs actually do very good research, without students. It's a reasonable way to go, once you have tenure.

Problem is, you can't take that route to get tenure in the first place, unless you're an absolute genius.

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by mbreese on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:39PM (#5255218)
Most places are redefining tenure though, so the only people that still have any meaningful resources are those that have extramural funding. Anymore, tenure means you get a closet for an office and a phone. And for new hires, if you don't have grant support, even with tenure, you can still lose your job.
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by pmb on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:30PM (#5255009)
Writing a grant proposal is about as hard as writing a paper. So if they apply for three grants and also write three papers in a year, then yeah - that's 50%.
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by montecarl on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @11:33PM (#5255394)
Getting a grant proposal accepted is much more difficult than getting a paper accepted.
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by javert on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:50PM (#5267444)
I don't think that's a valid generalization. It depends enormously on the funding agency and the place you're submitting the paper, respectively.

You're not going to be able to do a good grant proposal unless you have a good track record of research, with multiple papers. So in that sense, a grant proposal supersedes a single paper.

But, given that you've already done all those papers, a grant proposal is just writing, not new research, so it should actually be massively less work than doing all the original research that goes into a paper.

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by tomrod on Thursday February 21, 2013 @12:23AM (#5255589)
You ever hear of Horn from Horn & Johnson fame (Matrix Analysis)? Guy had a 9-5 for years and researched at nights in his home office. That would be my ideal setup, I think.
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by untangle on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:01PM (#5254315)
Good for you. You'll be in good company. These folks aren't HN-rich either: fighter pilot, fireman, teacher, social worker...
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by Xcelerate on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:04PM (#5254331)
[Retracted; I was conveying my point incorrectly.]
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by michaelochurch on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:09PM (#5254671)
I don't see that. I think that someone who complained about $250k would be laughed at, and even mocked openly. Especially keep in mind that we have international readers.

The relative compensation in many companies between engineers and useless managers is another issue... but anyone who complains about poverty at $250,000 can eat it.

Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by dishank on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @11:29PM (#5255370)
You make a good point with people relating PhD's with the amount of money you will make. PhD's not only have a cost of paying for university but also opportunity cost is also existent. Also I completely agree with your comment on the idea that you can live comfortably, not rich on a PhD.
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by aheilbut on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @07:44PM (#5254556)
4 years?
Re:The Ph.D Bust: America's Awful Market for Young Scientists by Xcelerate on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @08:30PM (#5254756)
For mine (chemical engineering in an American university). I hear it varies quite a bit depending on where you are and what you're doing it in.