Re:Mandiant Exposes APT1, One of China’s Cyber Espionage Units
by joequant on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @06:17PM
(#5247802)
One problem is that multinational corporations are multinational with significant operations inside of China. I doubt that the NSA is going to be of much help in helping a US company secure its networks inside of China, and if that company has large numbers of Chinese employees in China, there are security issues with having US intelligence companies sharing sensitive US intelligence.
For example, the NYTimes has a bureau in Shanghai, and if they use a private contractor to help strengthen their networks, then I don't think that the Chinese government would be cancelling visas. If the NYTimes brought in the NSA, then I give the Chinese government five minutes before all of the visa get cancelled and the journalists get expelled.
Re:Mandiant Exposes APT1, One of China’s Cyber Espionage Units
by greedo on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @09:12PM
(#5248546)
Defense is hard; that doesn't mean measures shouldn't be taken to protect your assets. However, due to how western businesses operate, it's almost trivial to successfully attack them. The attack surface is just too large, and most businesses can't afford security measures and restrictions that would truly make them safe.
That said, the threat vectors for APTs aren't always solely network-based. IIRC, the behavior of the APT that struck RSA was fairly targeted and changed behavior once inside the network. It isn't unreasonable to think that the NSA would want to talk about putting sensors inside a private network where they could detect "successful" penetrations.
Again, we have every right to be wary of letting the (government) camel nose in the tent. I'm just saying that if you don't kinda sorta trust your government to help you fight a serious foreign power with nearly unlimited resources, you might need to reconsider your position. The threat from China is real and ongoing versus the theoretical threat from the US Government.