Attending office hours is a great use of your time at a college, and showing up requires self-discipline and motivation.
I'm not arguing the point you're making. Nobody is. (Although many would argue that spending silly amounts of money is not a prerequisite to gaining access to esteemed faculty.)
Since you say you're arguing a different point: What exactly were you characterizing as hand-holding?
If several students have the same question, which is likely, then rather than having multiple individuals show up separately at office hours, a single post in a forum will answer that question for everyone, even those who didn't think to ask. This is a huge benefit to struggling students.
In general, MOOCs level the playing field in terms of socio-economic barriers to higher education. I believe this is the primary reason for their criticism. They erode the function of higher education in separating the haves from have-nots.
(Am I the only one who sees 'MOOC' and pronounces it /moose/ in my head?)
This actually makes more sense from a for-profit institution's point of view than it does for state-sponsored schools, but for whatever reason it started at the latter. I suppose seeing that attitude shift to the former as well shouldn't be too surprising.
The cost was more "real" to me because I knew where all those dollars came from and where they were going
>>Second, courses delivered solely online may be fine for highly skilled, highly motivated people, but they are inappropriate for struggling students who make up a significant portion of college enrollment and who need close contact with instructors to succeed.<<
A college education, at the very least, once signified that a graduate had the wherewithal to actually stick with something for four years and finish it. This included figuring out how to pay for those four years, figuring out how to live on your own and provide for yourself, and actually putting in the work to pass the required classes. A degree was a signifier of at least basic competence and dependability. At the very least, any college graduate you hired in 1980 was likely to be a decent employee.
But then we, as a society, decided that a college degree was an end in itself. We looked around and saw that most middle class people had college degrees, so obviously if we wanted to grow the middle class, we just needed more college graduates. And so we turned college into high school, part deux.
Now, a B.A. signifies little more than a willingness to borrow silly amounts of money and have instructors and administrators hold your hand through the entire process.
If those signing up for online classes are “struggling” or failing to even participate in those online classes, is that person really going to be a productive, high-skilled employee? I think the answer is pretty clearly no. So why do we continue to pretend that person needs a college degree?