News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Supreme Court to Hear Monsanto Seed Patent Case by belorn on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @03:29AM (#5243287)
With businesses whose sole businessmodel depend on government to grant an state enforced monopoly, one should really ask if government shouldn't take a more active part in determining the benefit and cost of said model.

When ever government go out and try to influence a market, they commonly do a cost-benefit analyzes. If they add a new regulation regarding health concerns in food processing, it is assumed that they do some form of balancing of cost and benefits. It is also assumed that we do not use the same cost and cost-benefit analyze they have laying around from the 19th century. Most people assume that what ever was true a few hundred years ago might have changed in the years and thus a new check regarding cost and benefits to society is in order.

When government goes out using patents to influence the market to produce more inventions, they don't do a cost-benefit analyzes. They barely even use the 200 year old check regarding previous invention, obviousness and discovery, as the number of inventions has increase beyond what is human possible to check. They just grant the same sized 20 years state enforced monopoly to anyone who ask, and hope that any problems will be solved by the court system.

The core of this case is how one should read the patent-exhaustion. It really shouldn't be about that. It should be about how and if the government should give aid to an company that invented, produced and successfully sold a grain that they modified with a discovered gene. It should be about the check and balance of the actions of government trying to influence the market with monopolies in an effort to encourage more inventions/discoveries regarding gene modified plants.

There are no comments on this comment yet.