The degree to which a business model is ill-conceived imparts no duty to other actors.
If the creation of this sort of tech is desirable -- and I'd argue that the market really, really wants this stuff -- then there's nothing weird about creating legal mechanisms that support it.
The problem I have here is that the patents are being used in a way here which serves only the innovator, and precludes better generic products over time. This fundamentally unbalanced by corporations which are greedy for both power and money, and in an area where the rights of the consumer are particularly important, namely food supply.
So it isn't enough to say:
> If the creation of this sort of tech is desirable -- and I'd argue that the market really, really wants this stuff -- then there's nothing weird about creating legal mechanisms that support it.
I think one also has to add, "provided that the rights and interests of other parties are respected and supported as well." That's what's wrong with Monsanto in this case (as well as Prometheus in their failed case last year, and the breast cancer gene patents, etc).
Regarding the Macbook analogy, agreed, but why would patent law hold true here ? Just trying to understand. A Macbook doesn't replicate by itself.
No, they don't [0]:
Because some stakeholders expressed concerns that this technology might lead to dependence for small farmers, Monsanto Company, an agricultural products company and the world's biggest seed supplier, pledged not to commercialize the technology in 1999.[2] Customers who buy patented transgenic seeds from Monsanto must sign a contract not to save or sell the seeds from their harvest,[3] which preempts the need for a "terminator gene".
Also, regarding this:
It's like me having to pay royalty to Apple for buying a used macbook :).
No, this is like your Macbook being able to make copies of itself, so that after you buy one, you've got a new copy every year for the rest of your life.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_use_restriction_technol...