News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by kevinalexbrown on Monday February 18, 2013 @04:27PM (#5240778)
This discussion is quite long, but for me it's really simple:

You don't say your site is ad-free if you get paid for links. Especially inside the donations pitch.

I don't care if you take donations, have a paywall, or sell advertisements (the ballet does all three, and that's awesome). Just be honest.

A maxim I use when trying to establish honesty: If you write a sentence that a substantial number of readers are misinterpreting, it's usually fair to call it an inaccurate sentence. If it's knowingly left there, it's usually fair to call it dishonest. Exceptions would include technically difficult material.

Edit: In this case, both the group paying her (Amazon) and Wikipedia refer to affiliate links as ads. I haven't polled her general readership, but that's a reasonable proxy for how the terms "ad-free" and "affiliate links" are interpreted.

https://affiliate-program.amazon.com/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affiliate_marketing

Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by arbuge on Monday February 18, 2013 @04:34PM (#5240839)
There's more than honesty at stake here... I'm pretty sure you could run into problems with the FTC (in the USA) if you disregard this principle. See for example http://bvyer.net/info/conduct. Other countries might have similar rules.
Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by larrys on Monday February 18, 2013 @05:21PM (#5241146)
"both the group paying her (Amazon) and Wikipedia refer to affiliate links as ads"

I believe that the reason that Amazon does this (I have an account) was intended to get around the sales tax issue by calling the payments for advertising as opposed to something that a State could take as "reseller" and translate to a presence and have a stronger leg for state sales tax from Amazon (not relevant given the recent changes but it was back when this practice started).

Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by radley on Monday February 18, 2013 @05:04PM (#5241043)
The difference is between solicited and unsolicited paid promotions. Popova thinks there's an obvious difference which goes without saying. Bleymaier thinks there's no difference and therefore attacked Popova for being morally bankrupt.

Sound about right?

Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by greyman on Monday February 18, 2013 @05:45PM (#5241285)
I would side more with Popova here regarding the aff links. She seems to having read hundreds and hundreds of books, and then she picks those which she found interesting and blog about them.

But what I see a bigger problem is that her asking for donation is presented to the reader as something which keeps the site ad-free, while it seems to be just another revenue stream.

Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by cubicle67 on Monday February 18, 2013 @07:51PM (#5241884)
The deception seems not about how to classify affiliate links, but rather deliberately leading the reader to infer that the blog's only income source is donations
Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by radley on Monday February 18, 2013 @08:09PM (#5241963)
Maybe so. It all boils down to recommendation versus promotion. I hate ads yet I'm totally comfortable with affiliate links on blog, so I consider her site to be ad-free.

Oddly, I don't like affiliate links in forums like HN.

Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by cubicle67 on Monday February 18, 2013 @08:57PM (#5242127)
It all boils down to recommendation versus promotion

No, I think that's a sidetrack. The issue, at least how I read it, is saying to the dear reader "please donate as that's my only income source"* when it's not true. It's deliberately deceptive.

What's odd is that there's nothing wrong, that I can see, with just being upfront about affiliate links - "Hey, want to support this blog? I get a small amount of money from any purchases made by clicking on the amazon links"

* Yes, I realise that's not the words she's using, but it sure is the message that's conveyed

Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by chobo on Monday February 18, 2013 @08:47PM (#5242107)
Why do you think one is okay but not the other?
Re:Making $1 million from affiliate links on "Ad-Free" blog by harlanlewis on Monday February 18, 2013 @10:37PM (#5242449)
I feel the same as grandparent, but it's a blurry line. Ideally, promoted ads should be recommendations. Buy more than just reach to a demo, instead ensure a qualified voice authentically highlights your benefits - more akin to social recommendations from friends than banner ads.

This is rarely attempted in a world of publications that depend on ad volume and outsourced ad buyer supply, but examples exist. The webcomic Penny Arcade recently ran a Kickstarter to achieve freedom from ads, but found itself answering questions like "What if I love ads?" (http://www.penny-arcade.com/2012/07/20/what-if-i-love-ads) because they'd built a reputation of only advertising products they would feel comfortable endorsing even without an adbuy (can't find a direct link to when they talk about this, but it's out there somewhere).