Re:Problems With Precision and Judgment, but Not Integrity, ...
by stcredzero on Monday February 18, 2013 @03:59PM
(#5240597)
> Asking journalists to be scientists removes the need for journalists.
Aww, crap. Just asking journalists to be a little less careless and fuzzy would be a good start. Opinions on this seem to be divided along two lines: 1) People familiar with getting quantitative things right in their jobs vs. others and 2) People who have had run-ins with careless/incompetent journalists vs. others.
> specifically points out that "extra" truth is different than truth in other situations.
I don't think he's saying that about truth. I think he's saying that about a field. It applies to truth -- it's just that our mish-mash of a culture hasn't caught up to that level of rationality yet.
Asking journalists to be scientists removes the need for journalists. You can say maybe we don't need journalists, but there clearly has to be different standards for science and journalism, even if only because of the vast differences in expected timeframes in each field.