Re:Problems With Precision and Judgment, but Not Integrity, ...
by stcredzero on Monday February 18, 2013 @03:46PM
(#5240532)
Well, to be fair, from the POV of an insider, I could see how it's a gray area when you get to the point of saying someone thought they were doing a good job, but it looks like he's incompetent at getting facts right and curbing his own bias. Sometimes you have to stop short of even being close to saying a colleague needs to be fired, and let those matters play out quietly later on.
Re:Problems With Precision and Judgment, but Not Integrity, ...
by wpietri on Monday February 18, 2013 @05:52PM
(#5241327)
That is understandable in any other employee at the Times, but it's a total failure in an ombudsman. They don't have to recommend firing; they can just say what happened and characterize is honestly. But they do have to always take the public's side, and they have to do it visibly.
This particular position was created after the Jayson Blair scandal, so it's particularly important that they are frank in calling out bad reporting. Or, in this case, explaining why they think it wasn't bad reporting.
The weird thing is, I think she's probably right. But I think the job of the public editor is precisely to address controversies of their reporters in sufficient detail that we don't have to trust her. Ombudsmen have to be seen as scrupulously fair to outsiders or there's no point in having them.