News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Killing It” Isn’t Worth It by mindcrime on Monday February 18, 2013 @02:26PM (#5240093)
“No matter how dark it gets, you should never, ever take your own life.

I'm sure this will be an unpopular position, but I question this. If an individual reaches a point where the pain and misery they are experiences outweighs the joy, or even the hope for joy, in their life then maybe the rationally correct thing to do is to take your own life.

I mean, if you reach a point where you can look forward and reasonably say "I'm never going to achieve my dreams and accomplish what I want to accomplish, and being here hurts" then why is one obligated to keep suffering until chance claims you?

I'm not saying this is a decision one should make lightly, and obviously one of the negatives is that it's an irreversible decision. But I can see circumstances where it is a reasonable choice.

Re:“Killing It” Isn’t Worth It by NhanH on Monday February 18, 2013 @07:08PM (#5241707)
The problem is that death is permanent, or irreversible, as you said. And that things change.

If there exists an omniscience being that can factually answer the question of "Will I ever achieve my dreams?" (or "Will I ever be happy again?", but that's for an even broader discussion), then yes, the only rationally correct thing to do is to take your own life for a "no" answer.

In reality, the best we can answer such question is "There would be x% chance thing will get better". At what value of x will the decision of taking one's life becomes rational?

And then, most of the time, depressed people aren't really in their best state of mind. Hence this is one of the cases where the advice should stay on the risk-adverse side, rather than the perfectly rational one.

Re:“Killing It” Isn’t Worth It by thebear on Monday February 18, 2013 @11:42PM (#5242659)
I'm never going to achieve my dreams and accomplish what I want to accomplish

Stephen Stills famously said, or rather sang, "If you can't be with the one you love, love the one you're with." Similarly, there are many dreams one can pursue, many things one can accomplish in life. If one dream turned out to be too far out there to reach, wait for the pain to pass (and trust me, it will), then go looking for a closer one. More often than not, it's right in front of your eyes. Suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem.