Re:Money Trees – Rap Genius Response to Heroku
by tibbon on Sunday February 17, 2013 @09:43PM
(#5237861)
Maybe this is offtopic, but I really don't like the way Rap Genius does links. It makes it so I essentially have to click on each link twice to get to what it actually goes to...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Money Trees – Rap Genius Response to Heroku
by teej on Sunday February 17, 2013 @09:50PM
(#5237882)
They're not links, they're text annotations. Rap Genius is a text annotation platform currently focused on rap lyrics. In this case most of the annotations happen to be a link + context, which is pretty rare.
Re:Money Trees – Rap Genius Response to Heroku
by tibbon on Sunday February 17, 2013 @09:52PM
(#5237894)
Yea, I got that... but in the context of a tech blog post, the interface just doesn't seem to make sense or at least in my head. Its a blog post, not rap lyrics.
Re:Money Trees – Rap Genius Response to Heroku
by teej on Sunday February 17, 2013 @09:56PM
(#5237900)
I think their hypothesis is something like all long-form text should/will be annotated. While I think it's important to dog-food, I agree that the execution in this case isn't great. The "links" really should just be links.
Re:Money Trees – Rap Genius Response to Heroku
by sequoia on Monday February 18, 2013 @10:43AM
(#5238752)
Agreed, this is incredibly annoying and has tipped the scales for me to "not worth the effort." It's as tho facebook attempted put a technical blog post in a status update and only used @tags or something; the content does not fit the format.
Basically it's breaking the web's "what happens when I click a link" contract; middle clicking should not open the same page in new tab, confusing me. Breaking that convention for a very specific purpose (annotating song lyrics) makes sense, but it's extremely misguided on a technical blog post.