News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our universe within a larger universe? So suggests wormho... by pdonis on Sunday February 17, 2013 @12:51PM (#5235994)
cutting the Figure 2 diagram along the "southwest-northeast" diagonal (the one on which B and C lie), and sliding one half of the diagram along that diagonal until B and C coincide.

After reading through the paper, that I think the transformation the author intends is somewhat different than what I described: what he is doing is cutting the Figure 2 diagram along the diagonal containing B and C, then flipping the top half over so that C coincides with B.

This is not a valid solution of the vacuum Einstein Field Equation (neither is the transformed spacetime I originally described, where the top half is "slid" along the diagonal), which the original spacetime diagrammed in Figure 2 (before any transformations to move C around) is. But the author is claiming that it is a solution if we put an infinitely dense sheet of lightlike radiation on the diagonal. This may be true mathematically speaking (I haven't verified it), but that doesn't make it physically reasonable. So I still think the paper's claims are not physically valid; they may describe a mathematically consistent solution, but it's not something that would ever happen in the real universe.

There are no comments on this comment yet.