Re:The Six Dumbest Ideas in Computer Security
by visitor4rmindia on Thursday March 19, 2009 @12:34PM
(#523553)
>How much usability do you lose to close a cross-site scripting attack? How much usability do you lose to close an SQL injection? How much usability do you lose to close a buffer overflow?
None of course. But these aren't philosophical security factors (like the OP). They could actually be classified as "security bugs" or just "bugs".
>how much usability do you lose from adopting two-factor authentication on top of a secure system? That can greatly add to a system's security, but you pay the price ("enter a number from this fob") once per login, hardly something to cry about.
Considering normal users - a whole lot!!! If I put in a system like this, I would expect a whole load of problems.
Consider: Delivery of fob, recall of fobs, damaged to fobs, lost fobs, stolen fobs etc etc. Not to mention about 20% of users would just hate learning how to use it.
None of course. But these aren't philosophical security factors (like the OP). They could actually be classified as "security bugs" or just "bugs".
>how much usability do you lose from adopting two-factor authentication on top of a secure system? That can greatly add to a system's security, but you pay the price ("enter a number from this fob") once per login, hardly something to cry about.
Considering normal users - a whole lot!!! If I put in a system like this, I would expect a whole load of problems.
Consider: Delivery of fob, recall of fobs, damaged to fobs, lost fobs, stolen fobs etc etc. Not to mention about 20% of users would just hate learning how to use it.