Re:Our universe within a larger universe? So suggests wormho...
by pdonis on Saturday February 16, 2013 @07:00PM
(#5233611)
Isotropic coordinates have a discontinuity at the event horizon.
No, they don't; I think you're thinking of Schwarzschild coordinates. Isotropic coordinates are continuous at the horizon, which is at R = M/2 (where R is the isotropic radial coordinate and M is the mass of the hole); but the region R < M/2 corresponds to the exterior of the horizon, not the interior.
The standard interpretation of this is that isotropic coordinates double cover the same exterior region (which is labeled region I on a Kruskal diagram like the one in Figure 2 on the ScienceDirect page); in other words, for every value of R < M/2, there is a corresponding value of R > M/2 that labels the same point in the same exterior region.
Poplawski's paper appears to claim that there is a valid alternate interpretation in which the region R < M/2 is a second, separate exterior region (labeled region III on a Kruskal diagram). That interpretation appears to me to violate the Einstein Field Equation, but I'm still digesting the paper (see my other posts in this thread).
No, they don't; I think you're thinking of Schwarzschild coordinates. Isotropic coordinates are continuous at the horizon, which is at R = M/2 (where R is the isotropic radial coordinate and M is the mass of the hole); but the region R < M/2 corresponds to the exterior of the horizon, not the interior.
The standard interpretation of this is that isotropic coordinates double cover the same exterior region (which is labeled region I on a Kruskal diagram like the one in Figure 2 on the ScienceDirect page); in other words, for every value of R < M/2, there is a corresponding value of R > M/2 that labels the same point in the same exterior region.
Poplawski's paper appears to claim that there is a valid alternate interpretation in which the region R < M/2 is a second, separate exterior region (labeled region III on a Kruskal diagram). That interpretation appears to me to violate the Einstein Field Equation, but I'm still digesting the paper (see my other posts in this thread).