The bigger problem than unfairness is that if you split 50/50 between two founders, you're screwed when you want to bring a third person in to do partner-level work.
That would be a tough situation, with no great solution.
Am I wrong in thinking you either bring in people from then on as employees?
I can't picture bringing on a 3rd and giving them a full founder stake down the road, and the middle ground is very tough.
Not allowing yourself to bring in key contributors in the future is an awfully big handicap to accept.
Allocating equity from a large pool, vesting and granting to the original founders as time goes on, and leaving a lot of headroom for future contributors seems like the right play.
If I am giving someone equity from an equity pool - I wouldn't consider them a founder. But that may just be semantics. Bringing in another founder down the road could work - it would just be a non-trivial decision to make regarding the split. Which slightly differs from what I originally, but I didn't mean to say I would completely rule that possibility out.
I definitely agree if you want to get and retain good people, having headroom in your equity pool is important.
You mention that you "prefer" this. IMO, this can never work, but I'm curious how/where it's worked successfully for you that you prefer it.
What if you realize that you need to add more executive-level people or even just regular employees to the company, or raise money?
I much prefer just splitting 50/50 and having both founders kick as much ass as possible. This does force you to be able to rely on your cofounder, but that is probably is a good idea (and unavoidable) anyways.