Re:Our universe within a larger universe? So suggests wormho...
by pdonis on Saturday February 16, 2013 @06:40PM
(#5233543)
Why do these articles get things wrong so often?
Different journals have different standards of rigor. I believe Physics Letters B, where this paper was published, is one of the less rigorous ones. They might also be more inclined to publish speculative papers, figuring that it's better to publish it and let someone else publish a refutation if it's wrong, as opposed to refusing to publish it in the first place.
In this case I think you're saying the paper itself should not have been using isotropic coordinates.
I suspect that the use of isotropic coordinates misled the paper's author, yes. I can't know for sure since I can't read the paper itself (it's behind a paywall). [Edit: someone downthread posted a link to an arxiv preprint; I'll take a look and respond further there.]
Is this because of different schools of thought in this higher realm of physics?
This could be a factor--it certainly is in some cases--but I'm inclined to think that in this case it's more a matter of a less rigorous journal being willing to publish a speculative paper, as above.
Re:Our universe within a larger universe? So suggests wormho...
by Osmium on Saturday February 16, 2013 @07:36PM
(#5233722)
I think you might be doing Physics Letters B a bit of a disservice there. I'm not saying it's the best, but it's certainly reputable and there are a lot worse...
Different journals have different standards of rigor. I believe Physics Letters B, where this paper was published, is one of the less rigorous ones. They might also be more inclined to publish speculative papers, figuring that it's better to publish it and let someone else publish a refutation if it's wrong, as opposed to refusing to publish it in the first place.
In this case I think you're saying the paper itself should not have been using isotropic coordinates.
I suspect that the use of isotropic coordinates misled the paper's author, yes. I can't know for sure since I can't read the paper itself (it's behind a paywall). [Edit: someone downthread posted a link to an arxiv preprint; I'll take a look and respond further there.]
Is this because of different schools of thought in this higher realm of physics?
This could be a factor--it certainly is in some cases--but I'm inclined to think that in this case it's more a matter of a less rigorous journal being willing to publish a speculative paper, as above.