News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by MaulingMonkey on Saturday February 16, 2013 @06:08PM (#5233439)
Maybe I'm an outlier here in game development, but "clueless kids" are the rule, not the exception, and nowhere near rare. Companies bin entire unsolicited design documents without even reading them because those ideas have negative expected worth: Increased chance of lawsuits, to a field rife and bountiful with ideas from people who've actually worked in the field and have some idea of what might work and what might not. Good ideas are as important as the air we breathe, but just as ubiquitous. They join our communities with those same ideas, offering $0 (not merely "reduced") wages, bringing no experience to the table, whether that be business acumen, marketing experience, writing artistic or coding skill... no finances as an investor, no guidance as someone who's already been in the industry, nothing. All for the promise of some nebulous undefined profit sharing on some idea they won't share a scrap of. Ostensibly to protect the idea from theft, of course, but leaving you with no idea if you might be interested even if they were offering something more.

Suggesting they learn to code might be inappropriate, but pointing out they need to be able to bring something to the table besides "ideas" -- any of the above skills would be a great start -- is exactly the sort of "sensible advice" called for, but that's often not enough to get through and make the point. When people start throwing around how much they're paid, they're trying to underscore what the "ideas guy" is competing with, to explain why that idea alone just isn't enough. When people start getting frustrated, angry, and ranty, perhaps it's because this isn't as rare as the author thinks. It certainly isn't rare in game development. Maybe a different approach would be appropriate, starting things off on "the right foot" by focusing on what they can bring to the table first, rather than the business opportunity. Resumes may get binned too, but not at the 100% rate. Focusing on the person rather than the idea also lets you focus on if you'd be a good fit for any project, rather than tossing one idea at a time their way... or if they're such a great fit you'd be willing to find a different business opportunity that suits both of you.

Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by Felix21 on Sunday February 17, 2013 @02:38AM (#5234514)
You have made a very great point, and i certainly was not aware that this "idea guy" problem is this bad in game development.

Maybe a different approach would be appropriate, starting things off on "the right foot" by focusing on what they can bring to the table first, rather than the business opportunity. Resumes may get binned too, but not at the 100% rate. Focusing on the person rather than the idea also lets you focus on if you'd be a good fit for any project, rather than tossing one idea at a time their way... or if they're such a great fit you'd be willing to find a different business opportunity that suits both of you.

I think if this is the common response the "clueless kids" get, there will much less clueless kids in the world. This response is infinitely more valuable than insults and rants.

Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by Deejahll on Saturday February 16, 2013 @05:37PM (#5233353)
A "business guy" complains about developers allegedly making contemptuous generalizations about clueless business guys by making contemptuous generalizations about developers.

He assumes that the reason that we who know how to write software don't (generalism) do his job is because we're "blind to those opportunities."

He sees himself as the architect and software developers as the grunts who lay the bricks.

Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by jrs235 on Saturday February 16, 2013 @06:14PM (#5233450)
His whole analogy of architects and builders falls apart once you realize as an architect of a business you have much less control and information as to what the market will actually do!

A building architect can design and make a blueprint based on knowing the qualities of various materials and a final outcome/design. That design isn't likely to change [much] after it is approved, unless the architect omitted something (or screwed up) or there are material issues.

Most ideas presented to 'coders' are half-baked. "I have this awesome idea! Let's build a building! With four bedrooms that will sleep a family!" "That's quite the well thought out blueprint there! Where do I start building?!"

Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by Felix21 on Sunday February 17, 2013 @02:30AM (#5234494)
Most ideas presented to 'coders' are half-baked. "I have this awesome idea! Let's build a building! With four bedrooms that will sleep a family!" "That's quite the well thought out blueprint there! Where do I start building?!"

Does that make it justifiable to respond with insults?

Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by Felix21 on Sunday February 17, 2013 @02:27AM (#5234489)
Software developers are not Grunts. They are hardworking creatives and certainly not grunts who lay bricks.

Also no where in the article did it say or imply that "those who know how to write software don't (generalism) do his job is because we're "blind to those opportunities.""

You obviously didn't read the article before writing this comment

Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by Longlius on Saturday February 16, 2013 @05:16PM (#5233262)
"You can code now shut-up about it already. You are a great developer and I am a great businessman; I have my skills and you have yours (well actually I now have yours to some extent)."

Really? I don't think so.

HN isn't populated exclusively with code monkeys. A lot of us have solid educational backgrounds, including some with graduate degrees and published research. To imply that you have our skills to 'some extent' is pure hubris on your part.

Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by ericclemmons on Saturday February 16, 2013 @05:29PM (#5233319)
My experience with "business people" almost always seems to be adversarial, as they tend to see the relationship in much the same way: combining mutually exclusive skill sets.

The problem is, developers are often very opinionated product guys, and they can execute! They typically don't have the insider knowledge on securing funding and navigating business politics.

The problem finally emerges when the developer is seen as only the executor of the vision, rather than a business man as well.

Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by Felix21 on Sunday February 17, 2013 @02:43AM (#5234521)
I am talking about enough skills to be able to execute on my ideas at least at the MVP level.

Definitely not comparing myself to a computer scientist, neither do I want to be one; I chose a Mechanical Engineering degree for good reasons.

Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by justjimmy on Saturday February 16, 2013 @05:25PM (#5233301)
Just a suggestion - run your articles through a spell checker. Makes it more credible when you share it with HN.
Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by Felix21 on Sunday February 17, 2013 @01:31AM (#5234396)
Thanks for the advice but a spell checker wont have picked up on the fact that I spelled Jeff Bezos's name wrong, which after looking at my article again is the only spelling mistake i spotted
Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by Adrock on Sunday February 17, 2013 @11:01AM (#5235547)
Also, you should be consistent with your grammar. Capitalizing everyone's first and last name except for "bill gates" in the middle stands out as sloppy. For better or worse, this affects the impression you make.
Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by aethertron on Sunday February 17, 2013 @02:13PM (#5236284)
First I was surprised that this was on the svtble network. (Then I looked again.)
Re:Leave The "Business Guys" Alone Already by joelmaat on Saturday February 16, 2013 @04:20PM (#5233084)
No.