As for Ember, I'm sure Ember is wonderful. I still haven't figured out what design decisions in Backbone drove develpers to create Ember, but I'm not qualified to question it. Either way, Ember and Backbone are both trying to solve the same basic thing: Providing an MVC framework for JavaScript, mostly focused on the browser. As I understand it, Ember wants to be a more complete toolkit than Backbone, which is very simple and minimalistic and leaves things like templating to other libs.
What is interesting is that Yehuda Katz was also behind Merb, which in my mind is a good example of a gratuitous project; Merb was someone reinventing Rails with the goal of being perhaps 10% better than Rails in the areas of performance and modalarity, while at the same time completely incompatible, and a lot of people jumped on the bandwagon. As it turned out, the developers decided to reimplement Merb's conceptual improvements back into Rails and shut the project down.
Again, I'm not qualified to critique Ember, but the Ember/Backbone competition certainly looks, on the surface, a lot like the Merb/Rails situation back in the day. I would love to hear more about why the devs decided to create Ember and not evolve Backbone. If the Backbone devs did not want to go in Ember's direction, that is of course a perfectly acceptable (if unfortunate) reason to start over.
This "X is old hat, use Y" phenomenon of "hype recycling" is part of a cultural problem that seems particularly endemic to the startup world. There is a lifecycle of "bleeding edge" to "mature" to "abandoned" that never lets up. There is always a newly-hyped library or framework or methodology that's trying to shift people's attention; and rather than refining and evolving the existing stuff into stability and maturity, many devs start new, wobbly, immature projects. But the bleeding edge is fickle, and when the dust settles there are some remaining competitors, but then suddenly the dust rises again and you're urged to abandon everything because the new stuff is in a separate programming language, so everything else is now incompatible; so the cycle goes. It results in a lot of work, and I like the competition and sheer energy of a developer community fired up about something, but I believe there is also a lot of work wasted.
Sometimes I wish software developers were more like engineers, and that people slowed down a bit. As one gets older, one gets to value maturity over novelty, and to see the importance of backwards compatibility, transition paths and careful releasing.